Click the Play button to listen to article

The Rajasthan High Court has set aside the charges framed under the Prevention of Corruption Act (the “Act”) against a practicing advocate, after highlighting that his role was confined to being a communicator, without there being any independent demand, solicitation or acceptance of illegal gratification on his part.

While further quashing the charges for criminal conspiracy under Section 120-B IPC, the bench of Justice Rekha Borana observed that mere presence of a person in chain of communication, without there being any evidence of meeting of minds or sharing of common object to commit the unlawful act, could not make the person a co-conspirator.

For context, the Court was hearing a criminal revision petition, in which the order of the special judge was challenged, that framed charges against the petitioner under Section 7A of the Act as well as under Section 120-B of IPC.

The allegation against the petitioner was that he mediated between the public servant and the complainant regarding the illegal demand and the gratification.

It was the case of the petitioner that he was not a government servant, but a lawyer, against whom charges under Section 7A of the Act, could not have been framed.

Further, it was contended that as per the transcript which was relied upon by the prosecutor, the petitioner only acted as a communicator of the demand made by the mediator. He neither made any demand, nor accepted any amount, nor did he act as a mediator to hand over the amount to the public servant.

After hearing the contentions, the Court highlighted that as per the records, the petitioner's role was confined to being a communicator, without there being any independent demand, solicitor, or acceptance of any illegal gratification.

“…it is undisputed that the petitioner is a practising advocate and does not hold the status of a 'public servant'. Section 7A of the PC Act talks of an undue advantage to influence a public servant by corrupt or illegal means…In absence of the said primary component to establish a direct or active nexus of corruption on his part, the invocation of Section 7A of the PC Act against a private lawyer definitely cannot stand.”

Further, in relation to Section 120-B, it was opined that mere presence in chain of communication was not enough, without there being evident meeting of minds or sharing of common objective of committing the unlawful act.

Accordingly, it was held that the trial court committed illegality in framing charges against the petitioner, and the charges were set aside.

Tags: