Telangana High Court Orders ₹2 Lakh Compensation In 2001 Alleged Fake Encounter Case But Refuses To Order FIR Citing Passage Of Time
| Police can't justify encounter killing as self-defence without supporting evidence, Court said.
The Telangana High Court has recently directed the State government to pay Rs 2 lakhs as compensation for the widow of a deceased man in an alleged fake encounter operation in 2001.
While doing so, the court also held that the State failed to follow the National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) guidelines for investigating police killings.
“…in a case of the present nature, where the death of an individual is sought to be justified by the respondent-State on the ground of exercise of the right of private defence, such a plea must be supported by cogent and specific material. Significantly, the respondent State has not followed the NHRC guidelines and investigated the matter… the respondent police authorities along with State are liable to compensate the petitioner for loss of her husband at the hands of the respondent Police authorities on the fateful day…”, the court observed.
The single judge bench of Justice Suddala Chalapathi Rao, however, refused to direct an FIR against the police officer in question, saying that over two decades had passed since the alleged incident.
“…now by efflux of time directing the respondent State to register an FIR and investigate into the matter, at this length of time, may not serve any purpose. More particularly, an investigation undertaken after such a long lapse of time may not yield any fruitful results, having regard to the difficulties in collecting evidence and ascertaining the actual circumstances existed, as on the said date…”, the court noted.
Hence, the writ petition was partly allowed, holding that the State's justification of the death as an act of 'private self-defence' was not corroborated by any evidence in the absence of independent investigation.
For context, according to the wife, her farmer-husband was shot dead at a toddy shop in December 2001 by armed policemen.
The police force, on the other hand, claimed that the deceased was a member of the banned People's War Group (PWG) organisation. As per the police, the shoot-out occurred when the police responded in self-defence to an attack by the Naxalites.
Before the High Court, the petitioner-wife alleged that the State refused to register an FIR against the erring police official, and instead registered a crime against the alleged PWG extremists, including the deceased husband,
Hence, the wife of the deceased man sought the court's intervention to register a murder case against the SI, as well as to grant compensation.
Advocate Vasudha Nagaraj, appearing for the petitioner, argued that the police had breached the 1997 NHRC guidelines, stipulating that deaths in police encounters should be treated as cognizable offences. In addition, such cognizable offences ought to be investigated by an independent agency, along with an FIR that may be lodged against police personnel if a specific complaint is made, the counsel told the court. It was further contended that the police's failure to conduct a fair investigation would entitle the petitioner to compensation under Article 21.
Appearing for the State Advocate Mahesh Raja, stated that the deceased died during an act of self-defence by the police.
The court agreed with the petitioner's stance that the 1997 NHRC guidelines were binding on the State when the alleged incident occurred.
“…Though the respondent State authorities washed out their hands by registering a case against the extremists and also the petitioner's husband, the respondent Police authorities were legally bound to register a case against the police personnel, who had participated in the alleged encounter, a proper investigation into the same should have been carried by a private agency and if it was revealed that the police firing was resorted to, purely in the exercise of the right of self-defence, no liability could have been fastened upon the respondent-State, no attempt of this nature was made by the respondents. However, when NHRC guidelines specifically envisages for registration of the same, the respondent police authorities have not followed the said procedure….”, the court said.
The court underscored that although the State claimed the death was a result of private self-defence, such a plea must be supported by cogent and specific material. Moreover, though a magisterial enquiry was ordered in 2002, no report or material was placed on record to establish its conclusion even after the lapse of two decades, the court remarked further.
Noting the aforesaid, the court directed the respondent police authorities and the State to pay a compensation of Rs 2 lakhs to the petitioner-wife within eight weeks for the loss of her husband.