Delay In Collecting Returned Petition Can't Be Excluded While Calculating Limitation Period: Tripura High Court
The Tripura High Court has held that the State cannot claim exclusion of the period spent in collecting an application returned by a court for lack of territorial jurisdiction when the delay was caused by its own negligence.A Division Bench of Chief Justice M.S. Ramachandra Rao and Justice S. Datta Purkayastha made the observation while dismissing an appeal filed by the State of Tripura...
The Tripura High Court has held that the State cannot claim exclusion of the period spent in collecting an application returned by a court for lack of territorial jurisdiction when the delay was caused by its own negligence.
A Division Bench of Chief Justice M.S. Ramachandra Rao and Justice S. Datta Purkayastha made the observation while dismissing an appeal filed by the State of Tripura against the rejection of its application challenging an arbitral award as time barred.
The dispute arose after an arbitral award was passed on December 28, 2018 in a matter involving the State and contractor. After receiving a certified copy of the award on January 2, 2019, the State filed an application under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act challenging the award before the District Commercial Court, Agartala on March 11, 2019.
However on August 20, 2021, District Court held that it lacked territorial jurisdiction and directed the State to present the application before the competent Commercial Court at Khowai. Although the application was ordered to be returned on that date the State collected it only on November 17, 2021 after a delay of 89 days. It then approached the Khowai Court on January 10, 2022.
The District Judge, Khowai rejected the application as time barred on November 6, 2024. The State challenged decision before High Court contending that period spent before the court lacking jurisdiction should be excluded under Section 14 of the Limitation Act, 1963.
The High Court noted that the State approached the District Court Agartala to get return of the application filed under Section 34 only on 17.11.2021 i.e., 89 days later, and it was so returned.
Rejecting the State's contention that the limitation must be counted from 17.11.2021 and not 20.8.2021 the court said:
"In our opinion, this endorsement by the Judge of the District Commercial Court, West Tripura, Agartala is an evidence only of the date on which the appellant had taken return of the application under Section 34 of the Act, and it is not evidence of the decision of the Court to return the said application, which decision had previously been taken by the Court on 20.08.2021 itself. So the limitation would have to be counted from 21.8.2021 and not from 17.11.2021
So the intervening period between 20.08.2021 and 17.11.2021 cannot be got excluded by the appellant under Section 14 of the Limitation Act,1963 and it cannot claim that the application presented on 10.01.2022 before the District Commercial Court, Khowai was filed within time".
The Bench further observed that the State had already exhausted 68 days out of the permissible 120 day limitation period and had only 52 days remaining to approach the competent court.
The Court observed:
"If the appellant's employees had been negligent in taking return from District Commercial Court, West Tripura, Agartala of the Section 34 application from 20.8.2021 to 17.11.2021, the appellant cannot take advantage of the said wrong and seek to exclude this period also under Section 14 of the Limitation Act, 1963."
The High Court also pointed out that even if the period was calculated from November 17, 2021, the State had taken 53 days to approach the Khowai Court exceeding the remaining 52 days.
Finding no error in the District Judge's decision, the High Court dismissed the appeal and upheld the rejection of the State's application as time barred.
Counsel for the Appellant: Additional Government Advocate Mangal Debbarma.
Counsel for the Respondent: Advocate Subhajit Paul.