Click the Play button to listen to article

The Supreme Court on Wednesday pulled up Shiv Sena (UBT) Rajya Sabha MP Sanjay Raut over his social media posts against the judiciary, observing that as a seasoned politician and parliamentarian, he should know the importance of restraint.

The bench comprising Justice Aravind Kumar and Justice Vipul M Pancholi was hearing a criminal contempt petition filed by the Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA) against journalist Nikhil Wagle and Raut over their alleged objectionable remarks against Chief Justice of India Surya Kant and the judiciary.

Senior Advocate Pradeep Rai, President of the SCBA, submitted that although Raut had expressed an apology for his remarks, he had subsequently made further social media posts attacking the judiciary. He cited a post made by Raut which alleged that the BJP has brought India's democracy, judiciary, central investigating agencies and the Election Commission under its control.

Rai also referred to a photograph posted by Raut showing the Supreme Court of Albania being burnt down by protesters, alleging that it carried an oblique message directed at the Supreme Court of India. He pointed out that Raut's affidavit did not disclose these subsequent posts and described him as a "habitual offender".

"He is in a respected position, so some responsibility is expected from you. This has to be dealt with an iron hand," Rai submitted.

Taking note of the submissions, Justice Kumar asked Raut to place his response to the subsequent posts on affidavit, adding that the Court would consider the matter thereafter.

"You have expressed apology. But in a matter of this magnitude, apology must come from the heart and not the mind. Mr Sanjay Raut, you are a seasoned politician. We have been hearing your speeches from advocate days. You are a seasoned parliamentarian, and you yourself were in the press. You should know what should be the restraint," Justice Aravind Kumar remarked.

Raut's counsel, while not endorsing his comments, requested the Court to take into consideration the fact that he was undergoing treatment for cancer and heart ailments.

Wagle Seeks Discharge After Apology

Senior Advocate Indira Jaising, appearing for Wagle, submitted that he had deleted the objectionable social media post and tendered an unconditional apology to the Chief Justice of India and the Supreme Court.

Jaising said that Wagle had complied with the Court's earlier direction to remain present virtually and requested that he be discharged from the contempt proceedings.

Opposing any direction requiring Wagle's physical presence on the next date, Jaising submitted that he had immediately taken down the post and apologised. She emphasised that Wagle was not seeking to justify his remarks but was acknowledging that they were a mistake.

Jaising also pointed out that Wagle was an award-winning journalist with several decades of professional experience and had never faced contempt proceedings. She added that he had himself approached the Supreme Court through petitions and had not boycotted the institution.

Senior Advocate Rahul Kaushik, however, submitted that Wagle should also be directed to appear physically before the Court on the next date, considering the nature of the language used against the CJI.

Justice Kumar, while observing that the journalist's role as part of the fourth estate carried responsibility.

"On a personal note, after becoming a lawyer, I saw my father's passport, in which it was written that the profession was journalist. It is the fourth estate. You know the Court has come to your rescue many a time," the judge observed.

Jaising reiterated that Wagle's comment was a slip. She added that a larger question of law regarding whether an abusive word against a judge would per se be contempt has to be examined.

The bench said that Wagle would also have to file an additional affidavit explaining his post.

About the petition

As per their petition, after the CJI declined to meet the delegation of Opposition parties in connection with ongoing protests in Delhi, Wagle posted from the account @waglenikhli stating: " **** you CJI".

SCBA, in its petition filed under Section 15 of the Contempt of Courts Act, has submitted that such a deliberate and intentional post made on social media by a senior journalist to a mass audience scandalises and tends to lower the authority of the Court.

SCBA says Raut also made false statements, alleging that judges attend political programmes of the ruling party and accept dinners hosted by Chief Ministers. Reportedly, he referred to the alleged photographs of judges playing badminton with political figures in London and imputed allegations against the CJI and other judges. He made these comments criticising the CJI's refusal to meet the Opposition Leaders on the SIR issue.

While granting consent, AG R Venkataramani observed that their comments are prima facie "scandalous and intended to lower the esteem of the Hon'ble Supreme Court, particularly the Chief Justice of India". The Attorney also pointed out that the comments concerning judges' playing badminton in London have been found to be false by the Delhi High Court.

The AG thus allowed the request made by SCBA President Senior Advocate Pradeep Rai.

Later, Wagle expressed an unconditional apology for his comment, saying that it was an emotional outburst, and that he has deleted the post.

 

Tags: