ECI Failed To Produce Records Showing Unanimous Approval Of SIR Decisions: Petitioner To Supreme Court
| The petitioner also contended that the subsequent corrective measures taken by the ECI after the writ petition do not validate earlier decisions.
The petitioner challenging the functioning of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar has contended before the Supreme Court that the Election Commission of India (ECI) has failed to produce contemporaneous records establishing that its decisions concerning the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls were taken unanimously by its three members, despite repeatedly asserting collective approval.
In a rejoinder affidavit filed yesterday through Advocate on Record Mudit Gupta, the petitioner Rakesh Kumar Singh has disputed the Election Commission's counter-affidavit and supplementary affidavit, in which the ECI contended that the decisions were unanimous.
He has argued that subsequent corrective measures undertaken by the poll body cannot retrospectively validate decisions taken without demonstrating compliance with Section 18 of the Chief Election Commissioner and Other Election Commissioners (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023.
“That the Respondents have asserted unanimity but have not produced a single contemporaneous record of any decision of the Commission on any act impugned. They have instead admitted that officers took steps needing correction, that the online statutory form was altered, that an officer re-allocated the Commission's internal work, that IT modules were not placed before the Commission, and that appeals affecting lakhs of electors were filed without the matter being brought to the Commission. Those admissions are the admissions of all three members. An assertion of unanimity is not proof of it. Administrative practice is not statutory authority. Subsequent correction is not authorisation at the time of the act”, the affidavit states.
The rejoinder has been filed in Singh's writ petition which challenges the functioning of the Election Commission and alleges that several decisions concerning the SIR exercise were taken unilaterally by Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar without the concurrence of the other two Election Commissioners.
The rejoinder affidavit is in response to the Election Commission's counter-affidavit, in which the poll body maintained that the SIR exercise was lawful and that all decisions concerning it were taken unanimously. The matter is listed for hearing tomorrow, November 17.
Petitioner seeks production of original records
The rejoinder challenges the Election Commission's reliance on assertions of unanimity without producing the underlying institutional records.
The petitioner has sought production of agendas, minutes of meetings, file notings, circulation sheets, resolutions, electronic approvals and communications concerning the impugned decisions.
The rejoinder argues that the Election Commission's affidavits do not disclose whether the decisions were actually taken by the Commission under Section 18 of the 2023 Act, or whether officers and administrative divisions acted without demonstrating the requisite approval.
It further contends that internal allocation of work or an officer's assertion that a communication falls within delegated authority cannot substitute for a decision of the Commission where the matter requires collective decision-making.
The petitioner has also questioned the Election Commission's reliance on Section 19A of the Representation of the People Act, 1951, and the Delegation Orders dated January 12, 1996 and September 9, 2012, arguing that the delegated functions do not encompass alteration of the statutory electoral registration framework or exercise of the Commission's collective decision-making powers.
The rejoinder challenges the Election Commission's defence concerning the additional declaration incorporated into the online Form 6 application during SIR.
The petitioner argues that the declaration introduced requirement for historical electoral-roll mapping, including information concerning the applicant's parents or grandparents, without a corresponding amendment to Form 6 prescribed under the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960.
The affidavit contends that the additional declaration effectively became compulsory for online applicants and could not be considered merely an administrative requirement or a separate document when its submission was necessary to complete the application process.
The petitioner disputes the Election Commission's assertion that Form 6 had not been amended, arguing that the actual operation of the online application process, rather than the nomenclature used by the poll body, must determine whether an additional statutory requirement was imposed.
The Election Commission had earlier acknowledged before the Supreme Court that displaying the SIR declaration alongside Form 6 online could have been construed as an amendment. It maintained that the declaration was a separate document and that the two were separated in the online application process from October 21.
The ECI subsequently removed the SIR declaration from the online Form 6 process and introduced a separate submission mechanism. The rejoinder argues that this subsequent separation does not establish the legality of the earlier arrangement or demonstrate that it had received the requisite statutory approval.
Corrective measures after writ petition do not validate earlier decisions: Petitioner
The petitioner has contended that corrective measures undertaken by the Election Commission after the writ petition was instituted, arguing that they do not answer the original allegations concerning the authority under which the impugned decisions were taken.
These include the Commission's September 26 press note, which stated that the additional declaration attached to Form 6 would continue to be used during the SIR but the forms prescribed under the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960 would apply outside the SIR period.
The rejoinder also refers to decisions dated September 26 and September 30 to constitute a committee to examine whether the ECINet portal complied with the applicable laws and rules, which was subsequently formally constituted through an October 14 circular.
The rejoinder also refers to an October 21 decision by the Electoral Rolls Division to separate the SIR declaration from the online Form 6 application, after the Commission acknowledged that displaying the declaration within the online form could give the impression that the statutory form had been amended.
The petitioner has also referred to a November 4 office order reallocating oversight of the IT/ICT Division to a Senior Deputy Election Commissioner, and a November 6 direction giving electors marked as Absent, Shifted, Dead or Duplicate (ASDD) another opportunity to establish their eligibility, with their existing EPIC numbers to be retained.
The rejoinder also refers to the November 3 clarification concerning prosecution under Section 31 of the Representation of the People Act, 1950, and the November 6 directions concerning electors categorised as Absent, Shifted, Dead or Duplicate (ASDD). The November 3 clarification stated that previously enrolled voters whose names do not appear in draft SIR electoral rolls can submit Form 6 to seek inclusion in the final electoral rolls and submitting Form 6 in these circumstances would not, by itself, constitute a false declaration merely because the applicant had been enrolled previously.
The rejoinder argues that subsequent administrative corrections cannot retrospectively establish that the original decisions were taken in accordance with Section 18 of the 2023 Act.
97 eligible electors in Goa left out: Petitioner
The rejoinder affidavit also highlights the case of 97 electors in Goa who were eligible for inclusion in the electoral rolls as per the ERO but could not complete the Form 6 application process through ECINet portal.
The petitioner alleges that despite repeated communications seeking assistance for these electors, the Election Commission failed to facilitate their inclusion.
The affidavit contends that the Election Commission's response has not adequately explained why the electors were unable to submit their applications or why the necessary facilitation was not provided.
The petitioner argues that the episode demonstrates the practical consequences of the additional declaration and the online application requirements imposed during SIR.
West Bengal SIR appeals filed without authorisation: Petitioner
The rejoinder further challenges the filing of appeals against orders passed by judicial officers against electoral roll exclusions during West Bengal SIR.
The petitioner alleges that appeals were filed by officers of the Chief Electoral Officer's office without demonstrating that the Election Commission had authorised the institution of such proceedings.
It also contends that the Chief Electoral Officer of West Bengal had not been informed of the basis on which the appeals were filed.
The petitioner has sought disclosure of the officers responsible for filing the appeals, the authority under which they acted, the criteria adopted and the relevant approvals and records.
The petitioner has sought production of the original records relating to the impugned SIR decisions. The rejoinder specifically seeks records concerning the SIR orders dated June 24, October 27 and November 14, 2025, the July 28, 2026 office order, communications concerning the allocation of IT/ECINet oversight, decisions relating to the online Form 6 declaration, and records concerning the West Bengal appeals.
It has also sought disclosure of the authority under which each impugned action was undertaken, whether the action was approved by the Commission, and whether the Commission's statutory decision-making requirements were complied with.