Sabarimala Reference : Live Updates From Supreme Court 9-Judge Bench [Day 11]

J Sundresh: this is a clear case of abuse of process of law

J Nagarathna: it will have devastating consequences

J Sundresh: we are very sorry to say that before a nine judge bench

Sr Adv: police protection was given to us

J Kumar: whether a resolution was passed [for filing PIL] and whether president was a signatory

Sr Adv: J Dipak Mishra said

CJI: don't take name of individual judges, he was not only the judge but also the CJI. question is simple, was there a resolution?

Sr Adv: to my knowledge, there wasn't

Sr Adv: [reads some report] the tanthri has mentioned that young women should not be permitted to entry the temple, a report of some prasanna-it is seen that deity doesn't like young ladies in the presence of the temple-is it in regard or insult of young ayyappa?

J Nagarathna: how are you concerned?

CJI: are you the chief minister of the country?

J Nagarathna: what is your business here?

Sr Adv: I am a woman, my womanhood has been attacked

J Nagarathna: can they not work for the welfare of the bar, for the country? do they have no business? work for younger members, work for people who come from the villages, they have no wherewithal

Sr Adv: what is a belief? I have taken belief from judgment of kerala high court

J Nagarathna: how does a juristic body, your association, have belief? it is individual who has belief, conscience

J Kumar: who is the president of this association

Sr Adv: some naushad

CJI: how do you reconcile with prayer a with para 3 on page 10-to allow the woman from 10 to 50 to ensure the entry-in para 3 you say you don't challenge the belief

Sr Adv: this is alleged everything that i am challenging the faith of others, so please see the prayers on pg 9 of written submissions

see prayer a-writ or direction for Kerala, Travancore Board to ensure entry of female devotees denied to them based on some ill-conceived news items

CJI: we understand that it was based on some news items

Senior Advocate(for Indian Young Lawyers Association): Please see pg 8, how this PIL has come up. there was four articles, one of Barkha Dutt, Sherwani Pandit, Veer Sanghi and one more.