Indira Jaising states that she must also be heard because she is representing the only two women in the case. Rajeev Dhawan says that he supports Nariman’s line of arguments; a question which was asked by the CJ.
CJI - Your last argument is that inherent powers cannot be used. We will consider this.
While reading out from his submissions, Nariman states that review is guided by a set of principles. It is not by way of appeal. Only when an opinion sought by the Executive, there is a reference; review is for a specific reason, a reference is for a question of law.
Order 40 Rule 1, which is different from Order 47. Whatever the nature of the proceeding, the nature of review cannot be equated to that of a reference.
He refers to a judgement with regard to the definition of a review. “The power of review is not an inherent power.”
Nariman states that the court only moves ahead when a case comes before it; there’s no movement of its own.
Nariman states that the court only moves ahead when a case comes before it; there’s no movement of its own.
Nariman refers to another judgement regarding Kerala Education Bill with a full court, rendered in a Presidential Reference. Case talked about advisory opinions.
Nariman : “The concrete case was the review. You may put forward your opinion, I’m not objecting to it. I’m objecting to the adjourning of the case.”
F S Nariman : In every review, outside material which has nothing to do with the errors in the case, cannot come in. There’s a whole line of cases for this.