Click the Play button to listen to article

The Supreme Court on Monday (November 16) held that gratuity of retired employees who were acquitted in a corruption case cannot be withheld merely because the State government's challenge to the acquittal is pending.

A bench of Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra and Justice Shree Chandrashekhar observed so while dismissing the appeals filed by the Delhi Development Authority (DDA) against a Delhi High Court judgment, which had upheld the Central Administrative Tribunal's (CAT) order directing release of gratuity with interest.

The Court further observed that the undertaking requirement has been imposed only to balance the competing equities of safeguarding public funds with the right of a retired employee to receive and enjoy terminal benefits earned over decades of service.

The respondents were employees of the DDA. In 2001, the Anti-Corruption Branch (ACB) of Delhi registered an FIR against the DDA officials, the Municipal Corporation of Delhi (MCD) officials and the officials of the Slum and Jhuggi-Jhopri Department, under Section 13(1)(d) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 (PC Act), read with Sections 420, 468, 471 and 120-B of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC/now Sections 318(4), 336(3), 340(2), and 61 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023/BNS). It was alleged that the officials had conducted a joint survey of slum dwellers to determine eligibility for relocation and alternate plots, and in connivance with property dealers, had included names of fictitious dwellers for wrongful gain.

In February 2017, the Special Judge (PC Act/ACB) convicted four of them and acquitted the respondents and seven others, while one accused was discharged for lack of sanction. Thereafter, the State government approached the Delhi High Court seeking leave to appeal against the acquittal. Notice was issued in August 2017. Later, both the respondents were provisionally promoted to the post of Research Assistant (Group B), subject to the outcome of the State government's challenge, and later superannuated.

Owing to the pendency of the leave petition, the DDA withheld their gratuity, amounting to Rs 18,52,224 and Rs 15,43,113 respectively, relying on Rule 69(1)(c) of the Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1972. For context. the Rule provides as under:

“(c) No gratuity shall be paid to the Government servant until the conclusion of the departmental or judicial proceedings and issue of final orders thereon: Provided that where departmental proceedings have been instituted under Rule 16 of the Central Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1965, for imposing any of the penalties specified in Clauses (i), (ii) and (iv) of Rule 11 of the said rules, the payment of gratuity shall be authorized to be paid to the Government servant.”

Later, the respondents approached the CAT. Relying on Kishan Lal Taneja v Government of NCT Delhi & Ors, the CAT directed release of the gratuity with interest, subject to an undertaking by each respondent to refund the amount with interest if the judicial proceedings were ultimately decided against them. Subsequently, DDA filed writ petitions before the Delhi High Court, which dismissed the plea and held that they should be disposed of in terms of Kishan Lal Taneja.

Aggrieved by the High Court's dismissal, the DDA approached the Supreme Court.

The Supreme Court noted that the DDA had not disputed that relief was extended to another acquitted accused in Kishan Lal Taneja, and had only argued that the decision was per incuriam. Rejecting this contention, the Court observed that “needless to say, such a contention cannot be accepted, especially given that other similarly placed persons have also obtained relief on the strength of Kishan Lal Taneja.” Further reliance was placed on Rajinder Khurana v Government NCT of Delhi & Anr and Laxmi Narain v Government of NCT of Delhi & Ors. wherein similar relief was granted.

The bench held that the reasoning in Kishan Lal Taneja applied equally to the respondents, who were acquitted after a full-fledged trial. It seconded the High Court's view that the pendency of the State government's application, with no stay on the trial court's judgment, “could not justify withholding the terminal dues of the retired employees after long years of service.”

The DDA further relied on Bikram Chand Rana v Himachal Pradesh Road Transport Corporation. However, the Court called this reliance “totally misplaced”, explaining that the case concerned an employee against whom departmental proceedings had concluded while the trial remained pending.

“Reliance on Bikram Chand Rana vs. Himachal Pradesh Road Transport Corporation is totally misplaced given that the said case pertained to an employee against whom the departmental proceedings had concluded, but the trial remained pending. The relied upon observations qua 'downstream' recovery were also made in that context i.e., future possibility of recovery from the employee could not justify releasing an amount that could otherwise not be paid in view of the express statutory embargo in Rule 69(1)(c) of the CCS Pension Rules. In this case, however, the amount has become payable once the trial concluded and resulted in the issuance of final order of acquittal therein. An Appellate Court may or may not disturb the same, but until then, the acquittal continues to hold the field.”

The bench also stressed the practical hardship of making the retired employees wait and observed as follows:

“Practically speaking, if a superannuated employee (being necessarily of advanced age) were required to await the conclusion of even appellate proceedings against acquittal for an uncertain number of years, it is most probable the pensionary benefits would itself be rendered illusory. They should not have to suffer due to long pendency of such a challenge preferred by the State, particularly when the delay is not attributable to them.”

In the light of aforesaid, the bench concluded that the condition imposed by the CAT and the High Court adequately safeguards the financial interests of the DDA.

“We are of the considered opinion that the condition imposed by the Tribunal and the High Court adequately safeguards the financial interests of the appellant-Authority.”

The appeals were accordingly dismissed.

Appearances:

For Appellant: Ms. Niharika Ahluwalia, AOR; Mr. Himaghn Jain, Adv.

For Respondents: Mr. Navjot Kumar, Adv.; Mr. Karan Khanna, Adv.; Mr. Vaibhav Manu Srivastava, AOR

Tags: