S. 223 BNSS | Accused Entitled To All Documents Relied Upon In Complaint; Right To Hearing Includes Written Submissions: Allahabad High Court
| HC clarifies that an application u/s 173 (4) BNSS cannot be automatically converted into a complaint merely because investigation is declined.
The Allahabad High Court has clarified that a proposed accused is entitled to receive a copy of the complaint and 'every' document annexed to and relied upon by the complainant before cognizance is taken on the same under Section 223 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS).
The Court has further held that the "opportunity of being heard" contemplated under the provision is not restricted to oral hearing and may also include written submissions.
A bench of Justice Santosh Rai issued a set of general directions for all Magistrates and Special Courts dealing with criminal matters in Uttar Pradesh while directing them to consider the legal objections raised by proposed accused persons and pass reasoned judicial orders before taking cognizance.
The Court clarified that proposed accused persons may file written submissions raising objections relating to "absence of territorial or subject-matter jurisdiction, Legal bar to prosecution, Limitation or statutory prohibition, absence of an essential ingredient of the alleged offence, that the allegations even if accepted as stated do not constitute the alleged offence etc".
The Court, however, cautioned that a Magistrate is not required to a minitrial at the pre-cognizance stage. It added that the Court must not undertake a roving inquiry, meticulously appreciate evidence, or adjudicate disputed defence contentions.
Justice Rai issued these directions while allowing an appeal filed by Manoj Kumar Paswan against an order of the Special Judge (SC/ST Act), Kanpur Nagar, which had converted his application under Section 173(4) BNSS into a complaint case.
Case in brief
The appellant (Manoj Kumar Paswan) had alleged that police personnel abused him by referring to his caste and made objectionable remarks that he belonged to a lower caste. The alleged action of the police pertained to the appellant's dispute with his neighbour.
He claimed complaints submitted by him and his family members to the police authorities had not resulted in effective action.
Subsequently, the appellant moved an application under Section 173(4) BNSS seeking police action and investigation.
However, the Special Judge directed that the application be registered as a complaint case and the matter was fixed for recording the complainant's statement under Section 223 BNSS.
Setting aside the order, the High Court clarified that an application under Section 173(4) read with Section 175(3) BNSS seeking police investigation must be examined on its own merits.
It held that such an application shall not automatically be converted into a complaint merely because the court is not inclined to direct an investigation.
"If the court considers it appropriate to proceed under the complaint procedure, specific reasons shall be recorded, keeping in view the nature of the allegations and the relief sought by the applicant", the Court directed.
It further stated that every such application must be examined after considering the allegations, supporting material and necessity of police investigation, while ensuring compliance with statutory requirements, including prior approach to the Superintendent of Police and filing of a duly sworn affidavit.
The Court directed that where an application is treated as a complaint, the procedure prescribed under Sections 223 to 227 BNSS must be strictly followed.
It held that the opportunity contemplated under the first proviso to Section 223(1) BNSS is mandatory and must be afforded before taking cognizance.
The Court specifically directed:
"The proposed accused shall be entitled, to receive copy of complaint as well as every document annex with and relied upon by the complainant in order to effective and meaningful 'opportunity of hearing' as provided under section 223 BNSS".
It further clarified that the expression "opportunity of being heard" under the first proviso to Section 223(1) is not restricted to oral hearing and may encompass written submissions as well.
It clarified that the proposed accused may place written submissions before the court raising specific legal objections. The Magistrate must consider material objections and pass a reasoned judicial order.
The Court also directed that these safeguards be followed where, after submission of a final report by the investigating officer, the court decides to reject it and treat the matter as a complaint case.
The High Court further directed Magistrates to independently examine the applicability of Section 223(2) BNSS where a complaint is proceeded with against a public servant.
Where applicable, the court must obtain a report from the officer superior to the concerned public servant and provide the public servant an opportunity to make assertions before taking cognizance.
However, the Court cautioned that Sections 175(4) and 223(2) BNSS shall not be applied mechanically merely because the proposed accused is a public servant.
"Their applicability shall depend upon the nature of the allegations and their reasonable connection with the discharge of official duties", it added.
The Court also directed Magistrates to carefully examine cases arising out of civil disputes, property disputes, financial or business transactions and previous litigation to determine whether the allegations independently disclose a criminal offence or whether criminal process has been set in motion with mala fide intent.
It clarified that an inquiry under Section 175(3) BNSS is not a full-fledged trial. Similarly, an inquiry under Section 225 BNSS must remain confined to determining whether sufficient grounds exist for proceeding against the proposed accused.
Further, whenever cognizance is taken in a complaint case, the order must expressly record that cognizance has been taken under Section 210(1)(a) BNSS, read with the applicable provisions of Chapter XVI BNSS or other applicable law.
On the facts of the case, the High Court found that the material placed before the Special Judge did not disclose a prima facie case either warranting a direction for investigation or justifying conversion of the application into a complaint case.
The Court noted that the police had initiated preventive proceedings against the appellant under Sections 170, 126 and 135 BNSS following a confrontation between him and his neighbour.
It also observed that no reliable medical evidence had been produced to substantiate the specific allegation that the appellant was assaulted with 25–30 blows.
The Court clarified, however, that these circumstances could not by themselves be treated as conclusive proof that no offence had been committed.
Holding that the Special Judge had failed to properly examine the material and the statutory safeguards governing the initiation of criminal proceedings, the High Court set aside the order.
It directed that a copy of its general directions be circulated to all judicial officers in Uttar Pradesh through the Registrar General and the Director of the Judicial Training and Research Institute (JTRI), Lucknow, for dissemination and inclusion in judicial training programmes.
Advocate Gyanendra Kumar, holding brief of Advocate Babu Lal Ram, appeared for the appellant
AGA RK Shukla appeared for the State