Even Partial Penetration Is Sufficient To Constitute Rape: Allahabad High Court Upholds Conviction In 1982 Incident
The Allahabad High Court recently upheld the conviction of a man for committing the offence of rape against a minor girl in 1982 while reiterating that a complete penetration is not necessary to constitute the offence of rape and that even partial penetration is sufficient in law.
Dismissing an appeal filed by the appellant-accused, Justice Abdul Shahid found that the possibility of some degree of penetration could not be ruled out in the circumstances of the case, although complete penetration may not have taken place.
The Court categorically found that the accused had proceeded beyond the stages of intention and preparation and had entered the stage of execution of the intended act.
The appellant had moved the HC challenging the judgment of January 1984 passed by the III Additional Sessions Judge, Fatehpur, which had sentenced him to 4 years of rigorous imprisonment for the offence of rape.
Case in brief
According to the prosecution's case, the incident took place on July 10, 1982, when the victim had gone to graze cattle in a forest. The accused was also grazing his cattle in the area.
The prosecution alleged that the accused forcibly pushed the girl to the ground and attempted to insert his penis into her private parts. Upon failing to do so, he repeatedly inserted his finger, causing bleeding.
The victim raised an alarm, following which persons from the village reached the spot and challenged the accused, who fled.
The victim's father lodged a written report at a Police Station in Fatehpur on the next day and he also handed over her blood-stained underwear to the police.
As per the radiology examination, it was opined that her age at the time of examination could not have been more than 14 years. The doctor assessed her age at approximately 14 years.
Before the HC, the appellant argued that he had been falsely implicated due to previous enmity between the parties. He also pointed to alleged inconsistencies in the victim's statements regarding the manner of the occurrence and the nature of the act.
It was further contended that the medical evidence did not conclusively establish rape, particularly because the doctor had admitted that the injury could also have been caused if the victim had fallen face downwards on a pigeon pea stalk or another hard object.
It was also argued that no external injuries had been found on her body.
High Court's observations
Considering the victim's statements, the High Court noted that the accused had attempted to insert his private part into hers and, upon failing, inserted two fingers, resulting in bleeding.
The Court observed thus:
"The commission of an offence generally involves three stages, namely, intention, preparation and execution. In the present case, according to the statement of the victim, the accused had proceeded through all three stages in furtherance of his intention to commit rape".
It further held:
"During the entire process, the possibility of some degree of penetration cannot be ruled out, although complete penetration may not have taken place".
The Court added that even if the act did not culminate in the commission of completed penetration, the conduct of the accused clearly demonstrates that he had proceeded beyond the stages of intention and preparation and had entered the stage of execution of the intended act.
In this regard, the High Court referred to the explanation to Section 375 IPC, which provided that penetration was sufficient to constitute the sexual intercourse necessary for the offence of rape.
The Court also referred to the principle that the depth of penetration is immaterial. It further added thus:
"The only thing to be ascertained is whether the private parts of the accused did enter into the person of the woman. It is not necessary to enter into any nice discussion as to how far they entered".
Furthermore, the bench noted that the victim's testimony was material and inspired confidence. It further noted that she had categorically described how the appellant forcibly took her to the ground and committed the alleged act.
The medical examination revealed that the victim's hymen was ruptured, there was slight bleeding at the 7 o'clock position and she complained of pain on being touched.
The doctor also stated that only one finger could barely be admitted into her private part and opined that she had been subjected to rape.
The Court observed that these findings substantially corroborated the victim's testimony and were consistent with the prosecution's account of the time of occurrence.
It further held that the doctor's admission of a possible alternative explanation for the injury did not render the entire prosecution version unreliable.
"Medical evidence is generally corroborative in nature and cannot, by itself, displace otherwise reliable ocular testimony," the Court observed.
On the absence of external injuries, the Court held that this was not sufficient to discredit the victim's testimony. It said that the nature of the assault described by her and the internal findings recorded by the doctor could not be ignored merely because no external injury was noticed.
The High Court also rejected the argument that contradictions in the victim's statements had undermined the prosecution case.
It said that some variations regarding the precise manner of the occurrence and the part of the victim's body involved were discernible in her statements recorded during investigation and trial.
However, it said that these variations, when considered in the context of her overall testimony, did not demolish the substratum of the prosecution case.
Finding no perversity, illegality or misappreciation of evidence in the trial court's judgment, the Court affirmed the conviction and sentence awarded under Section 376 IPC and dismissed the appeal.
Since the appellant was on bail, the Court directed him to surrender before the trial court and to undergo the remaining sentence.