Allahabad High Court Orders Man's Custody For Video Recording Its Hearing; Bars Litigants From Carrying Mobiles Into Courtrooms
| Open justice does not mean free broadcast; court proceedings are not for entertainment purposes, says High Court
The Allahabad High Court today ordered the custody of a man who was found recording court proceedings on his mobile phone without the Court's permission.
The Court directed that he appear tomorrow before the HC to explain why he was recording court proceedings when he had no interest in any matter listed, and why it should not be treated as interference in the administration of justice.
Furthermore, the Court directed that, from now on, litigants shall not be permitted to enter courtrooms carrying mobile phones. The Registrar General has been directed to paste a notice to this effect at the High Court's pass counter.
The Court added that if any litigant is found with a mobile phone in the courtroom, then the concerned Advocate would be solely responsible for the same
A bench of Justice Vikram D Chauhan passed this order while hearing a petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.
During the hearing, the Additional Government Advocate informed the Court that a person was recording the proceedings on his mobile phone.
When called upon, the person identified himself as Raj Kulshrestha. He admitted that he was recording the proceedings without the Court's permission but could not explain the purpose behind doing so.
After his mobile phone was taken into custody by the Bench Secretary and opened, the Court found that 2 videos of the proceedings had been recorded.
The Court noted that Kulshrestha had no case listed before it and was carrying a pass issued by the Registry which permitted access only to the Advocates' Chamber.
He had nevertheless entered the courtroom without a proper pass and could not explain why he was present there or why he had recorded the proceedings.
"Mr. Raj Kulshrestha shall be taken into custody and shall be produced tomorrow i.e. 20.11.2026 at 10.00 am. Mr. Raj Kulshrestha shall be produced before the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Prayagraj and shall be medically examined before being kept in custody as directed by CJM, Prayagraj," the Court states in the order.
The Court, however, clarified that if he applies for bail and furnishes personal bonds and 2 sureties to the satisfaction of the CJM concerned, he could be released on bail on condition to appear before the HC tomorrow.
The order further records that Kuldeep Batra, whose matter was listed before the Court at Serial No. 27, was also present with a pass meant only for access to the Advocates' Chamber. Batra stated that he did not know Kulshrestha.
Taking exception to this, the bench stated that it is not in the interest of the litigants that their personal details be broadcast on social media.
The Court added that the court proceedings are not for entertainment purposes but is a serious business affecting liberty and rights of an individual
"The publishing or recording such judicial proceedings without leave of the Court may have the effect of social media trial without even the final determination in the court proceedings and may adversely affect the court proceedings or the right of litigant. There may be prejudice caused to the persons, whose cases are being listed and argued before this Court. The victims may also have to face social media stigma, if their facts or harassment is uploaded on the digital network," the Court remarked.
The Court observed that it exercises jurisdiction over criminal cases, including matters concerning individual liberty, child sexual abuse, the CBI, the Enforcement Directorate and MPs/MLAs.
Such cases, it noted, involve facts which are not required to be published on social media without determination by the Court.
The bench said that the principle of open justice means that court proceedings are generally open to the public to attend. However, it clarified that this does not amount to a right of "free broadcast" by an unauthorised individual.
In its order, the Court also took note of submissions made by Senior Advocate C.P. Upadhyaya, President of the Allahabad High Court Bar Association, who informed it that some advocates were engaged in recording and uploading videos of court proceedings.
He submitted that such conduct was not in consonance with the decorum of the Court and seriously objected to it.
Upadhyaya further informed the Court that he had circulated a notice dated November 18, 2026, to members of the Bar. The notice stated that making videos, reels or photographs inside the High Court premises, including courtrooms and corridors, was prohibited.
The notice warns that an advocate found doing so would have to deposit a penalty of Rs. 5,000 with the Bar Association and could face disciplinary action, including possible termination of membership.
The advocates who had allegedly brought Kulshrestha into the courtroom were also directed to appear the next day and show cause why proceedings should not be initiated against them.
The Registrar (Protocol) was also directed to ensure that persons without proper passes are not permitted to enter courtrooms and that passes carry an endorsement prohibiting mobile phones for litigants and persons other than advocates attending proceedings.
The Court directed that Kulshrestha's mobile phone be kept in a sealed cover and produced before it the next day.