Third Party Claiming Ownership Or Possession Doesn't Automatically Become Necessary Party In Eviction Suit: Allahabad High Court
The Allahabad High Court has held that a third party asserting an independent claim of ownership, tenancy or possession over premises forming the subject matter of a pending Small Causes Court suit cannot seek impleadment merely because a decree in the suit may affect the rights so asserted. The position is no different, it held, where the claim rests on a tenancy said to have been created...
The Allahabad High Court has held that a third party asserting an independent claim of ownership, tenancy or possession over premises forming the subject matter of a pending Small Causes Court suit cannot seek impleadment merely because a decree in the suit may affect the rights so asserted.
The position is no different, it held, where the claim rests on a tenancy said to have been created after the eviction suit was instituted.
Justice Dr. Yogendra Kumar Srivastava held,
“An independent dispute relating to ownership, title, possession or a separate relationship of tenancy cannot ordinarily be introduced into an eviction suit through an application under Order I Rule 10 CPC, unless its determination is shown to be necessary for deciding the controversy involved in the suit.”
Respondent no. 1 sued respondent no. 2 in 2018 for eviction from commercial premises at Village Sadarpur, Dadri, Gautam Buddh Nagar, and for arrears of rent, pleading he was her tenant. He denied being a tenant or in possession, saying one Manoj ran a business there as a tenant of revisionist no. 1.
Revisionist no. 1 claims to have executed a sale deed dated 22.07.2016 in favour of respondent no. 1 for 100 square yards, and has sued for its cancellation in Original Suit No. 38 of 2018. The revisionists say Manoj was her tenant until 31.12.2019 and that revisionist no. 2 was inducted from 01.01.2020 to run coaching classes.
Their application under Order I Rule 10 read with Section 151 CPC for impleadment as defendants was rejected by the Additional District Judge, who found nothing on record evidencing the alleged tenancy, noted that the registered sale deed stood undeclared void, and held that title fell outside a suit confined to the landlord-tenant relationship. They came in revision under Section 25 of the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act, 1887.
The Court held that Order I Rule 10(2) CPC exists to enable complete adjudication of the controversy actually before the Court. It relied on the decision of the Supreme Court in Kanaklata Das and Others v. Naba Kumar Das and Others where it had held landlord and tenant to be the ordinarily necessary parties to an eviction suit.
“A third party does not become a necessary or proper party merely by asserting an independent claim of ownership, title, interest or possession in respect of the premises forming the subject matter of the suit. The same principle applies to a claim founded upon an independent relationship of tenancy, including one alleged to have arisen subsequent to the institution of the suit.”
Applying this, the Court held that revisionist no. 1's ownership claim was an independent dispute already pending in Original Suit No. 38 of 2018, the sale deed's validity needing no determination to decide the landlord-tenant controversy. The tenancy claimed by revisionist no. 2 from 01.01.2020 post-dated the suit and did not alter the controversy as it stood at institution; the GST, VAT and sales tax registrations relied upon established no tenancy in his favour, held the Court.
Clarifying that the refusal to implead decided none of the revisionists' independent claims, and expressing no opinion on Original Suit No. 38 of 2018, the sale deed or the alleged tenancy, the Court dismissed the revision.