The Allahabad High Court has held that an allottee is entitled to the benefit of zero period from the date of allotment itself where the development authority allotted and leased out a plot knowing that an order of status quo stood in the way of delivering possession.

The Court also held that once the cancellation of an allotment is set aside in revision, the plot stands restored by legal fiction, leaving the authority with no occasion to charge the allottee for restoring it.

The bench of Justice Siddhartha Varma and Justice Kunal Ravi Singh held,

“In light of the above, it is clear to us that interest of justice would require us to grant the benefit of zero period from the date of allotment as otherwise the Authority would benefit from its own wrong. The Authority being fully aware of the restriction imposed upon it by the first status quo order chose to proceed further. Therefore, the conduct of the Authority does not justify the non-grant of zero period from the date of allotment.”

The petitioner's bid for a commercial builder plot in Sector 43, NOIDA, was accepted on 26.07.2007 and the plot allotted the next day at a premium of ₹9,31,07,197.58, the balance of ₹6,98,30,400/- being payable in 16 equal instalments. A lease deed was executed on 04.01.2008 and possession on paper followed on 20.02.2008. Physical possession never came.

Land in Sectors 42 and 43 had earlier been allotted to Kendriya Karamchari Sahkari Greh Nirman Samiti Limited and then cancelled, prompting the Samiti to sue the Authority. In the Samiti's First Appeal From Order, the High Court directed the parties to maintain status quo on 10.11.2006, more than eight months before the petitioner's plot was allotted.

The suit was decreed in 2008, and a fresh status quo order was passed on 29.01.2009 in the Authority's appeal. Only on 22.07.2016, on the Authority's own application, was that order confined to the 3,24,000 sq. meters to which the Samiti had been held entitled.

The petitioner stopped paying instalments. A show cause notice of July 2013 was followed by cancellation of the allotment and determination of the lease on 14.10.2013. The Authority offered restoration in 2014, but only against restoration charges.

In revision under Section 41(3) of the U.P. Urban Planning and Development Act, 1973 read with Section 12 of the U.P. Industrial Area Development Act, 1976, the State Government on 08.07.2024 set aside the cancellation and the refusal of restoration and zero period, directing the Authority to reconsider and pass a speaking order. The Authority did not challenge that order.

Three fresh orders followed. The plot was restored with charges, penal interest was levied on three instalments due before 29.01.2009, zero period was allowed only from that date, and the demands were quantified: restoration charges of ₹1,63,60,868/-, penal interest of ₹57,82,697/-, the entire balance premium, lease rent and interest on it. All three orders were challenged.

The revisional order having gone unchallenged, the Court held, the setting aside of the cancellation was final, and the Authority had again failed to make amends for its earlier mistakes.

“Once the cancellation of the allotment was set aside then by necessary legal fiction, the plot stood restored and therefore there was no discretion left upon the Authority to examine the issue of restoration and imposition of restoration charges.”

On the zero period, the Court observed that the Authority knew of the suit over Sectors 42 and 43 and of the first status quo order when it made the allotment.

“Despite being aware of first status quo order, the Authority chose to execute a lease deed in favour of the petitioner without disclosing the actual location of the allotted plot.”

Holding that the zero period had to run from 27.07.2007, the Court set aside the penal interest as well, the liability to pay the instalments having shifted to the close of that period. On the demand for the whole premium, it noted that the Authority's own payment schedule ran until 23.04.2031 and that its counter affidavit was silent on the point.

“There is no denial of the liability to pay the premium, but the liability is contingent upon 16 instalments given to the petitioner.”

Whether lease rent is payable where physical possession has not been given was, the Court held, no longer res-integra. Following Vision Town Planners Private Limited v. State of U.P. and 2 others and M/s Silverline Furnishing And Furnitures Private Limited v. State of U.P. and others, it set aside the lease rent and the interest on it, to be raised only once possession is given.

Allowing the petition, the Court directed that the zero period run from 27.07.2007 until actual physical possession, that possession be delivered within two weeks of production of a certified copy of the order, and that the premium be recalculated in 16 equal instalments. No non-development or time extension charges may be imposed, and the petitioner will have two years from possession to complete construction.

Tags: