If the mindset of "unleashing" penal prosecution against the constitutional right to protest gains traction, it would be a sad day for democracy, observed the Bombay High Court while quashing a First Information Report (FIR) against a man booked for staging protest over the poor state of a road in Chandrapur district, wherein, a vehicle turned turtle, killing one passenger.
Sitting at the Nagpur bench, single-judge Justice Mahendra Chandwani noted that the applicant Nishkarsh Nimgade, was part of an alleged unlawful assembly which was agitating for the removal of the Public Works Department (PWD) officers, who constructed a substandard road, where a tragic accident took place.
The judge noted that the only allegation against the applicant was that he along with other persons was agitating for removal of the errant PWD officers.
The judge pointed out that it is a settled law that prosecution must not be launched to stifle agitation that are part of democratic process so long as the people do not take the law into their own hands or indulge in violence or damage to public or private property.
"Article 19(1)(b) of the Constitution guarantees the right to assemble peaceably and without arms. While reasonable restrictions could always be imposed on exercising this fundamental right, such right must not be diluted or stifled based upon vague charges bereft of the essential ingredients to constitute offences under the penal laws. The lines between the constitutional right to protest and the unleashing of penal prosecutions cannot be allowed to be blurred. If this mindset gains traction, it would be a sad day for democracy," the judge observed.
In the order passed on October 29, the judge, while commenting on the merits of the case, noted from the charge sheet that it does not reveal that the people who gathered on the spot by tying rope across the road obstructed any person from proceeding in any direction through the road. The judge found no whisper in the entire charge-sheet as to who was obstructed from proceeding from one direction to another.
"Not a single statement of any passerby is recorded whose right of way had been obstructed by the people who gathered on the spot. Therefore, the ingredients of Section 126 of the BNS are not attracted against the applicant. There is nothing on record to suggest as to who was obstructed by the people who gathered on the spot. There is no evidence at all in the entire charge-sheet to that effect. Therefore, it can hardly be said that the offence of forming an unlawful assembly has been committed by the people who gathered on the spot," the judge opined.
Noting the facts of the case, the judge said that the assemblage of people who gathered on the spot to agitate, however large, cannot be said to be illegal.
"In order for it to be illegal, the assemblage must be inspired by an illegal object as specified in Section 189 of the BNS. Merely because a large number of persons gathered to agitate against the condition of the road and insisting for action against the erring officials of PWD department and the contractor, it cannot be presumed that the people gathered on the spot formed an unlawful assembly," the judge explained.
Appearance:
Advocates Purushottam Patil, NA Waghmare, Vinay Rathi and Yash Ghodichor appeared for the applicant.
Additional Public Prosecutor HD Futane represented the State.