Click the Play button to listen to article
story

The Bombay High Court has permitted a minor rape survivor to undergo medical termination of her 28-week pregnancy, directing that the State must assume complete responsibility for the newborn if the child is born alive and the parents are unwilling or unable to care for it.This after the Medical Board examined the survivor and opined that medical termination of pregnancy can be permitted with...

Your free access to Live Law has expired
Please Subscribe for unlimited access to Live Law Archives, Weekly/Monthly Digest, Exclusive Notifications, Comments, Ad Free Version, Petition Copies, Judgement/Order Copies.

The Bombay High Court has permitted a minor rape survivor to undergo medical termination of her 28-week pregnancy, directing that the State must assume complete responsibility for the newborn if the child is born alive and the parents are unwilling or unable to care for it.

This after the Medical Board examined the survivor and opined that medical termination of pregnancy can be permitted with due risks, but warned that the foetus may be born alive and may require NICU Care. 

The Court this emphasised that a child born alive following a court-permitted termination must not be neglected or left to perish.

A Division Bench of Justice Advait M. Sethna and Justice Ranjitsinha Raja Bhonsale was hearing a writ petition filed by the 17-year-old survivor and her father, seeking permission to terminate the pregnancy beyond the 24-week statutory limit under the Medical Termination of Pregnancy (MTP) Act, 1971. The survivor alleged that she was sexually assaulted by a 19-year-old acquaintance.

The Court also referred to an earlier decision of the Bombay High Court in XYZ v. Union of India, which held that where a child is born alive following a court-permitted medical termination, the registered medical practitioner and the hospital must assume responsibility for providing the child with the best medical treatment available.

Expressing its agreement with the cited decisions, the Court held:

“… under no circumstances, the child, if born alive in the present case, must be neglected or left to perish or completely at the hands of fate which is as uncertain as is unknown. This particularly, in a situation like present, where the women or her family members may not be in a position or are not willing to assume responsibility of the to be born child.”

The survivor's counsel submitted that the minor was unwilling to continue the unwanted pregnancy and that doing so would cause grave mental, physical and emotional trauma. The Court also interacted with the survivor and her parents, who expressed their inability to care for the child owing to their bad financial circumstances. The survivor also conveyed that she did not wish to continue the pregnancy under any circumstances.

The Court noted that the petitioner is determined to terminate the pregnancy and has completely detached herself from considerations such as whether the child would be born healthy or is viable, which are not relevant to her. The Court further noted the opinion of the Board that the medical termination of pregnancy can be performed considering the possibility of grave and irreparable harm to the psychological health of the survivor.

The Court relied on the Supreme Court's decision in A (Mother of X) v. State of Maharashtra, which permitted termination of a 30-week pregnancy of a woman who had conceived as a minor. It noted that the Supreme Court had observed:

“… the reproductive autonomy and bodily integrity of a pregnant woman must be given sufficient emphasis over the rights of unborn foetus… forcing a woman to continue an unwarranted pregnancy causes visceral trauma and ignores the physical and mental transformation that a woman's body undergoes.”

The Court expressed concern over an earlier case before its Kolhapur Circuit Bench in which a child born alive after termination was not provided treatment for approximately 11 hours and consequently died. It observed that such an incident must never recur.

Accordingly, the Bench permitted termination of the pregnancy. It directed the hospital to provide post-delivery care to the survivor and neonatal care to the baby, if required.

Full View
Tags: