Click the Play button to listen to article

The Gauhati High Court has directed the Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF) to grant retrospective seniority to a constable appointed in 2017 pursuant to a 2009 recruitment process, after he was denied appointment despite securing the same marks as the last selected candidate.

Justice Nchumbemo Mozhui held that a candidate wrongfully denied appointment is entitled to notional seniority from the date on which he ought to have been appointed. The Court also directed the CRPF to notionally fix his pay at par with his batch mates from 2010 but denied him back wages for the period during which he had not served.

Rejecting the CRPF's contention that the constable's seniority could only be counted from his actual appointment in 2017, the Court observed:

“Under such circumstances, the claim of the respondent authorities that the case of the petitioner would be covered under Rule 8 (f) of the CRPF Rules 1955 cannot be accepted by this Court and accordingly declined.”

The Court further held:

“On the above settled principle of law, a candidate who is wrongfully not appointed, is entitled to notional seniority from the date he should have been appointed. This principle ensures that employees are not penalized for delay or errors made by the employer.”

The petitioner had applied for the post of Constable (General Duty) pursuant to a CRPF recruitment advertisement issued in 2009. He cleared the physical efficiency, physical measurement and written tests by securing 43 marks. However, he was initially declared medically unfit. After a review medical examination he was declared fit in July 2010.

Despite securing the same marks as the last selected candidate, he was not appointed as the authorities gave preference to older candidates.

Petitioner approached the High Court, which in March 2016 directed the CRPF authorities to treat him as a selected candidate against normal wastage vacancies and offer him consequential appointment. He was eventually appointed on January 31, 2017.

Petitioner subsequently approached the Court seeking seniority and pay fixation at par with candidates appointed through the same recruitment process in 2010.

The CRPF opposed the plea by relying on Rule 8(f) of the CRPF Rules, 1955 which provides that a constable takes seniority from the date of his first appointment. Since Petitioner had joined service only in 2017, the authorities argued that he could not claim seniority from the earlier recruitment process.

The High Court however noted that its earlier orders had already directed the authorities to treat petitioner as a selected candidate against normal wastage vacancies and offer him consequential appointment.

While granting the relief, the Court also considered the principle of “No Work No Pay” and clarified:

“The petitioner shall not be entitled for any actual monetary benefits for the periods not served including arrears but from the date of joining the post by the petitioner.”

Accordingly, the Court directed the CRPF to grant Petitioner notional seniority from the date of selection under the 2009 recruitment advertisement at par with his batch mates and notionally fix his pay at par with them from 2010.

The writ petition was accordingly allowed.

Counsel for the Petitioner: Ms. T. Wapangla.

Counsel for the Respondents: Mr. U.K. Goswami, Central Government Counsel.

Tags: