Click the Play button to listen to article
story

The Gauhati High Court has imposed costs of Rs. 25,000 on a man for repeatedly approaching the Court concerning his appointment as a Lower Division Assistant (LDA) in Assam Government which had already been held illegal in earlier proceedings.Justice Manish Choudhury dismissed the Petitioner's fourth writ petition seeking pensionary and other retirement benefits observing that his...

Your free access to Live Law has expired
Please Subscribe for unlimited access to Live Law Archives, Weekly/Monthly Digest, Exclusive Notifications, Comments, Ad Free Version, Petition Copies, Judgement/Order Copies.

The Gauhati High Court has imposed costs of Rs. 25,000 on a man for repeatedly approaching the Court concerning his appointment as a Lower Division Assistant (LDA) in Assam Government which had already been held illegal in earlier proceedings.

Justice Manish Choudhury dismissed the Petitioner's fourth writ petition seeking pensionary and other retirement benefits observing that his repeated attempts to litigate issues arising from the same appointment amounted to an abuse of the process of law.

“Although, the prayer made in the present writ petition, which is the fourth one, are couched in a different manner, a look at the manners in which the petitioner had structured his previous three writ petitions, it becomes evident that the core issue in each of the four writ petitions revolves around the appointment of the petitioner in the post of Lower Division Assistant, which was found to be non-existent.
Evidently, the issue raised in the present writ petition is relatable to the matter of appointment of the petitioner in the post of Lower Division Assistant only. Thus, the core issue was and is the same. Therefore, such repeated filing of writ petitions on the same core issue is clearly an abuse of the process of law and of the court.”

The petitioner claimed that he was engaged as an LDA (lower division assistant) in the Assam Elementary Education Department on August 5, 1996 pursuant to a verbal instruction from the then District Elementary Education Officer based on a note from the Minister of Irrigation, Assam.

In 2005, the High Court had refused to regularise his service holding that he had not been appointed through any selection process and that the Minister had no authority to make such an appointment. His service was subsequently terminated through an order dated October 26, 2005.

The petitioner filed a plea before the high court in 2016 contending that the termination order had never been communicated to him. The High Court dismissed the petition in January 2017 by imposing costs of Rs. 5,000. The Division Bench upheld the decision and the Supreme Court subsequently declined to interfere.

He thereafter challenged the termination order through a third writ petition in 2018 which was dismissed by the High Court in January 2025 after observing that the validity of the termination order had already attained finality.

In the present petition, the petitioner sought pensionary benefits including gratuity, earned leave and Group Insurance Scheme benefits. He relied on an Assam Government Office Memorandum dated September 6, 2003 which provides pensionary benefits to government servants who have completed 20 years of continuous service even if their services have not been confirmed.

He argued that he had worked continuously for over 20 years and had received regular salaries until May 2017.

Rejecting the claim, the Court observed that the petitioner's appointment had already been held illegal in the earlier proceedings. It held that the 20 years of continuous service contemplated under the Office Memorandum must be rendered as a government servant. Since the petitioner had never been legally appointed to government service thus his receipt of salaries for over 20 years could not make him eligible for pensionary benefits.

The Court also noted that although the petitioner was seeking a different relief in the present petition, the core issue in all four proceedings remained the same, which is his alleged appointment as an LDA.

Referring to the Supreme Court's decisions in Devilal Modi Versus Sales Tax Officer, AIR 1965 SC 1150 and M. Nagabhushana versus State of Karnataka, (2011) 3 SCC 408, the Court reiterated that the principles of constructive res judicata apply to writ proceedings under Article 226 of the Constitution. A litigant cannot repeatedly initiate proceedings by raising new grounds or seeking different reliefs arising from the same cause of action when the underlying issue has already attained finality.

“The present venture by the petitioner for the fourth time is a complete misadventure. This approach on the part of the petitioner for the fourth occasion seeking the above reliefs is clearly in abuse of the process of law, which is to be visited with exemplary cost.”

The Court also rejected the petitioner's reliance on the purported Terminated Employees (Temporary Benefits) Act, 2022, pointing out that the document was merely a private member's Bill and had never become an Act.

While imposing costs of Rs. 25,000, the Court took note of the petitioner's age and directed him to deposit the amount before the Registry within one month. The amount is to be transferred to the Gauhati High Court Bar Association.

Counsel for Petitioner: A.R. Bhuyan, Senior Advocate, assisted by A. Sarif

Counsel for Respondents: S. Konwar and R.M. Baruah

Tags: