The Himachal Pradesh High Court has held that a subsequent amendment to Recruitment and Promotion Rules prescribing additional educational qualifications cannot invalidate a promotion that was validly granted under the rules prevailing at the time of promotion.

Division Bench of Justice Ajay Mohan Goel and Justice Yogesh Jaswal remarked that: “If a person already stands promoted to a particular post as per the prevailing Rules and subsequently, the R & P Rules qua the said post are amended and certain qualifications are added..the promotion of that person.. as per the Rules existing at the time when the promotion was made, becomes bad in law and such an incumbent then has to be demoted.”

The petitioner, Ranjit Singh Thakur, challenged the placement of Devi Singh as Senior Sheristedar in the District Judiciary, Solan, on the ground that he did not possess the minimum educational qualification of 10+2 prescribed under the amended Himachal Pradesh District Judiciary Staff Rules, 2022, notified on October 16, 2024. He contended that Devi Singh was consequently ineligible for promotion to the post of Chief Administrative Officer.

The respondents submitted that Devi Singh had been promoted as Senior Sheristedar on November 3, 2017, when the applicable rules prescribed matriculation as the minimum qualification.

They also pointed out that he had already been promoted as Chief Administrative Officer on May 8, 2025, before the petitioner filed the writ petition.

The High Court observed that Devi Singh had been promoted as Senior Sheristedar on November 3, 2017, in accordance with the eligibility criteria prescribed under the rules then in force. It held that the subsequent amendment dated October 16, 2024, introducing the minimum educational qualification of 10+2, could not retrospectively invalidate his existing promotion or require his demotion.

The Bench further clarified that the amended qualification applied prospectively to future promotions from the specified feeder categories. Since Devi Singh was already holding the post of Senior Sheristedar when the amendment came into force, his eligibility for promotion to Chief Administrative Officer was not affected by the amendment.

Accordingly, the Court dismissed the writ petition, holding that the petitioner's challenge to Devi Singh's placement and subsequent promotion was misconceived.

Date of Decision: 03.11.2025

Tags: