'Wife's Preference For Independent Accommodation Not Always Cruelty, Family Circumstances Must Be Considered': Jharkhand High Court
The Jharkhand HC has held that a spouse's preference for independent accommodation cannot automatically be treated as matrimonial cruelty. The Court observed that while examining allegations of cruelty arising from a demand for separate residence, courts must consider the surrounding circumstances, the needs of the parties, their obligations towards dependent family members and the manner in which the demand was made.
A Division Bench of Justice Sujit Narayan Prasad and Justice Pradeep Kumar Srivastava upheld the dismissal of a husband's divorce petition, holding that the Family Court's judgment rejecting his claims of cruelty and desertion did not warrant interference.
The case arose from a marriage solemnised on November 25, 2007, in Arrah, Bihar. Two children were born from the marriage. According to the husband, his wife had refused to live in a joint family and had objected to the presence of his deceased sister's three children, who were residing with him. He alleged that she had pressured him to send his elderly and ailing father to their native place and had subjected him to mental and physical harassment.
The husband further claimed that his wife frequently quarrelled with him, used derogatory language, physically assaulted him, scratched his face, tore his clothes, threw household articles at him and repeatedly threatened to commit suicide. He also alleged that she had lodged false complaints against him before the State Women's Commission and police authorities.
The husband had earlier instituted proceedings under Section 9 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, seeking restitution of conjugal rights. Those proceedings were disposed of following a settlement before the Mediation Centre, Ranchi, on May 30, 2018. He subsequently approached the Family Court seeking dissolution of marriage under Sections 13(1)(ia) and 13(1)(ib) of the Hindu Marriage Act on the grounds of cruelty and desertion. On May 2, 2025, the Principal Judge, Family Court, Ranchi, dismissed his divorce petition. Aggrieved, the husband approached the High Court.
Examining the allegations concerning separate residence, the High Court noted that the husband had claimed his wife refused to reside in the matrimonial home and insisted that he arrange a separate flat. The wife, however, maintained that the husband had himself arranged the rented accommodation and that she was not permitted to reside with him in the matrimonial home.
Distinguishing between unreasonable conduct and a spouse's preference for separate accommodation, the Court observed:
“In this regard, it is necessary to distinguish between a spouse's unreasonable conduct and a demand for separate residence which may arise from the circumstances of the matrimonial relationship. A spouse's preference for independent accommodation cannot, in every case, be treated as cruelty. The surrounding circumstances, the needs of the parties, their obligations towards dependent family members, and the manner in which the demand was made must all be considered.”
The Bench noted that the parties had, in fact, lived in rented accommodation at Singh More following the earlier mediation proceedings. However, it held that their residence in separate accommodation could not, by itself, establish that the wife had subjected the husband to cruelty. Emphasising the need to establish conduct satisfying the statutory threshold of matrimonial cruelty, the Court held:
“The evidence must demonstrate that her conduct in this regard was of such a nature and degree as to satisfy the statutory test. A demand for separate accommodation, without sufficient evidence of accompanying oppressive or abusive conduct, cannot automatically be elevated to the level of matrimonial cruelty.”
The Court also considered the husband's allegation that his wife had instituted false complaints against him. It observed that the institution of a criminal complaint by one spouse against the other does not automatically constitute matrimonial cruelty. The nature of the allegations, circumstances surrounding the complaint, conduct of the complainant and outcome of the proceedings are relevant considerations.
The Bench further examined the husband's plea of desertion and found no apparent illegality or perversity in the Family Court's conclusion that the ground had not been established.
Accordingly, the High Court dismissed the husband's appeal and upheld the Family Court's judgment dated May 2, 2025, and decree signed on May 16, 2025, refusing to dissolve the marriage.
Appearance:
For the Appellant-Husband: Mr. Atanu Banerjee, Advocate
For the Respondent-Wife: Mr. Dilip Kumar Karmakar, Advocate