CISF Officer's Suicide Attempt: Karnataka High Court Calls For Periodic Mental Health Assessment Of Security Personnel Entrusted With Firearms
The Karnataka High Court has suggested security and police organisations to examine their existing policies and appropriate steps be taken to undertake welfare measures for personnel serving in the armed forces, police and other security organisations to strengthen their mental health.
Further the court has directed framing of appropriate systems for assessing the mental health and fitness of personnel both before entrusting firearms and periodically thereafter.
A single judge bench of Justice Suraj Govindaraj said “Personnel entrusted with protecting the lives and safety of others must themselves be provided care, support and reasonable assistance when they face personal or mental health difficulties.”
Emphasising that personnel serving in armed forces are also human beings and have families, responsibilities and personal problems. They experience grief, anxiety, financial difficulties, marital discord, illness in the family and other difficulties.
The court observed, “The expectation that they must remain available for duty at all times and discharge their responsibilities, come rain or shine, irrespective of their personal circumstances or mental condition, requires a change in institutional thinking. Discipline and dedication are essential, but they cannot be demanded at the cost of ignoring the basic human needs of personnel.”
The bench added “A force which looks after the mental and physical well being of its personnel is better equipped to maintain discipline, operational readiness and public safety.”
Regulating Access to Firearms
The bench underscored that mental health is directly connected with operational readiness and public safety, particularly in the case of personnel entrusted with firearms. Following which it directed “In the case of personnel entrusted with firearms. The authorities must have appropriate systems for assessing the mental health and fitness of such personnel, both before entrusting firearms and periodically thereafter, with provision for reassessment whenever circumstances warrant.”
It added “Suitable procedures must also exist for regulating access to firearms where a genuine safety concern arises, while ensuring that such preventive measures do not become punitive or result in automatic exclusion from service.”
The court also suggested that the commanding and supervisory officers must be sensitised to recognise signs of distress and facilitate appropriate assistance. “Personnel who undergo treatment or experience mental health difficulties must also receive suitable support for rehabilitation and return to duty, based on professional assessment,” the court said.
The court gave the directions while quashing the attempt to commit suicide proceedings initiated against a 37-year-old woman sub-Inspector in the Central Industrial Security Force (CISF), who in 2022 had tried to take her life by shoting a bullet in her abdomen from her service pistol.
The victim survived and recovered as she was immediately rushed to the hospital. However, she was put through a departmental inquiry, a criminal case under Section 309 of the Indian Penal Code, came to be lodged. Seeking discharge in the criminal proceedings she moved the trial court which rejected her application. Following which she moved the High Court.
Advocate Tarunn Surana appearing for the petitioner informed that she was under severe mental distress on account of her inability to conceive. After years of unsuccessful treatment, she developed severe depression and, in that state of mind, used her service pistol to shoot herself in the abdomen, directing the shot towards the part of her body which she associated with her inability to bear a child.
Reliance was placed on section 115 of the Mental Health Act 2017, (Presumption of severe stress in case of attempt to commit suicide) and argued that use of the expression “shall be presumed” makes the presumption mandatory, and the further direction that such person “shall not be tried and punished under the said Code” protects the person from prosecution and punishment under the IPC, unless the presumption is rebutted.
Section 115 places the burden of rebutting the presumption upon the prosecution
The bench noted that the provision removes the element of culpability which attaches to an attempt to commit suicide under Section 309 of the IPC and requires a person who attempts suicide to be regarded as a victim of circumstances, rather than as an offender, in the absence of proof to the contrary. “The legislative approach is to treat such a person as one in need of care, treatment and rehabilitation, rather than penal sanctions,” it said.
Emphasising that the provision is not a matter of discretion for the Investigating Officer or the Court. It must be given effect to unless the prosecution establishes material to rebut it.
The court made it clear that “Section 115 of the MHC Act, 2017 does not repeal or efface Section 309 of the IPC, but it displaces the operation of Section 309 in respect of a person who has attempted to commit suicide and is presumed to be under severe stress, unless the prosecution rebuts that presumption.”
Further it said “An Investigating Officer is required to examine the circumstances in which the attempt is alleged to have been made and collect material, if any, which may rebut the presumption. The decision to file a charge sheet under Section 309 of the IPC must be taken after giving effect to Section 115 and considering whether the material collected establishes the contrary.”
Further the court said that the Magistrate is equally required to consider the said presumption while deciding an application for discharge under Section 239 of the Cr.P.C.
The court referring to the circumstances in the case at hand said “The fact that she directed the firearm at herself, and specifically at the part of her body which she associated with her infertility, is a circumstance consistent with the statutory presumption of severe stress under Section 115. The prosecution has not placed any material capable of rebutting the statutory presumption.”
The bench allowed the petition and held “The impugned order dated 26.12.2024 does not consider the effect of the statutory presumption or examine whether the prosecution material contains anything capable of rebutting it. It also does not consider the circumstances in which the petitioner sustained the gunshot injury, including the medical history relied upon by her. The petitioner is, therefore, entitled to be discharged from the said offence.”
Appearance: Advocate TARUNN SURANA for Petitioner.
HCGP RANJITH KUMAR N for R1.