Kerala High Court Upholds Reinstatement Of Former State Bar Council Secretary, Modifies Finding Of Fraud Against Bar Council To 'Negligence'
The Kerala High Court has dismissed two writ appeals filed by the Bar Council of Kerala and its present Secretary, R. Hari Babu, challenging a Single Judge's judgment allowing the former Secretary Simy S.'s challenge to the termination of her service through the purported acceptance of her resignation. [2026 LiveLaw (Ker) 642]It also modified the Single Judge's observations...
The Kerala High Court has dismissed two writ appeals filed by the Bar Council of Kerala and its present Secretary, R. Hari Babu, challenging a Single Judge's judgment allowing the former Secretary Simy S.'s challenge to the termination of her service through the purported acceptance of her resignation. [2026 LiveLaw (Ker) 642]
It also modified the Single Judge's observations attributing fraudulent conduct to the Bar Council, substituting them with findings of negligence and recklessness.
A Division Bench comprising Dr. Justice A.K. Jayasankaran Nambiar and Justice Preeta A.K., dismissed the appeal and held that the resignation tendered by Simy on January 7, 2026, could not have been validly accepted after she withdrew it on the following day.
The Court further held that the Bar Council had failed to take a considered decision on the resignation in accordance with the applicable statutory rules.
Simy S. was appointed as the Secretary of the Bar Council of Kerala on February 28, 2025, following a selection process involving a written examination and interview.
On January 7, 2026, during a meeting of the Bar Council's Executive Committee, she tendered a letter of resignation addressed to the Chairman of the Bar Council. The Chairman of the Executive Committee, who was physically present at the meeting, endorsed the letter. The Bar Council subsequently claimed that its Chairman had also received and accepted the resignation on the same day.
However, on January 8, 2026, Simy submitted another letter withdrawing her resignation and requesting permission to resume her duties.
Meanwhile, the Special Secretary informed her that she should refrain from discharging the duties of Secretary pending a final decision by the Bar Council on her resignation.
At its meeting on January 20, 2026, the Bar Council purportedly ratified the Chairman's decision to accept the resignation with effect from January 7, 2026. This decision was communicated to Simy through letters dated January 21, 2026.
Simy approached the High Court challenging the action and has also questioned the subsequent appointment of R. Hari Babu as Secretary in the vacancy created by her alleged resignation.
The Single Judge allowed the writ petition, finding that the resignation had not been validly accepted before its withdrawal. The appointment of Hari Babu had also been made subject to the outcome of the writ petition through an interim order dated April 22, 2026.
The Bar Council and Hari Babu approached the Division Bench by the present appeal challenging the Single Judge judgment.
The Court examined whether the Rule 23 of Chapter VII of the Bar Council of Kerala Rules, 1979, governing the resignation of staff members, applied to the post of Secretary.
Rule 23 provides that any member of the staff intending to leave service may do so after giving one month's notice of such intention to the Bar Council.
The appellants argued that the Secretary constituted a separate category from other staff members and that the provision should not apply to the Secretary. It was also submitted that Rule 23 merely envisaged that the resignation would take effect only with effect from a prospective date unless the competent authority has accepted the resignation letter, by waiving the notice period, before the expiry of the notice period.
It was submitted that in the present case, the subsequent ratification by the Bar Council, of the decision of Chairman of the Bar Council was prior to the expiry of the notice period and hence the provisions of Rule 23 did not have any bearing on the legality of the decision taken by the Bar Council.
The Court did not accept the submissions and noted that the Secretary and other staff of the Bar Council of Kerala are appointed under Section 11 of the Advocates Act, 1961.
The Bench observed that Section 11 of the Act refers to the Secretary and other persons on the staff of the Bar Council. This, the Court noted, indicated that the Secretary was also included within the expression 'staff' for the purposes of the Act and the applicable rules.
The Court held that although separate provisions existed concerning the qualifications, tenure, remuneration and duties of the Secretary, that did not exclude the Secretary from the general service conditions applicable to staff members.
“We are therefore of the view that Rule 23 under Chapter VII of the Rules would apply to govern the resignation of a Secretary as well.” the court held.
The Court clarified that the resignation tendered on January 7, 2026, would ordinarily have taken effect only from February 7, 2026, unless the competent authority, namely the Bar Council itself, consciously decided to waive the notice period and accept the resignation earlier.
The Court held that the Bar Council of Kerala, being the appointing authority, was also the competent authority to accept the resignation and decide whether the prescribed notice period should be waived.
The Court found that the endorsements allegedly made by the Chairman of the Executive Committee and the Chairman of the Bar Council on January 7, 2026, did not demonstrate any application of mind regarding the waiver of the notice period or the reasons justifying acceptance of the resignation.
The subsequent communications, including the letters issued on January 21, 2026, merely indicated that the resignation had been received and forwarded for consideration by the competent authority.
The Bench observed that the Bar Council itself had not applied its mind to these statutory requirements at any stage.
“In the instant case, the endorsements allegedly made on the resignation letter dated 07.01.2026 tendered by the writ petitioner, by the Chairman of the Executive Committee and Chairman of the Bar Council of Kerala, do not reveal any application of mind by them on the aspect of waiver of notice period or indicate the reasons that weighed with them for accepting the resignation.” Court observed.
It therefore held that there was no considered decision by the Bar Council, either independently or through ratification, to accept Simy's resignation.
The Court also emphasised that the decision to accept a staff member's resignation by waiving the prescribed notice period had to be taken by the Bar Council itself and could not be delegated to another person.
The appellants relied on the Supreme Court's decision in Delhi Technological University v. B.S. Rawat [2026 INSC 797], to contend that the Chairman's acceptance of the resignation could be retrospectively validated through subsequent ratification by the Bar Council.
The Division Bench examined the principles governing the doctrine of ratification discussed by the Supreme Court. It reiterated that ratification can retrospectively validate an act initially performed without authority, provided the competent authority itself approves the action.
However, the Court stressed that ratification cures defects of authority and cannot validate an act that is inherently illegal or one that could not have been lawfully performed in the first place.
In the present case, the endorsements made on the resignation letter did not indicate that the Chairman had consciously decided to waive the notice period or had recorded reasons for accepting the resignation.
The Court held that for an unauthorised decision to be capable of subsequent ratification, the decision itself must have complied with the substantive requirements of the statutory provisions.
“In other words, while the decision to be ratified may have been taken by one who did not have the authority to take it, the decision itself had to be one that complied with the requirements of the statutory provisions.” the Court observed.
Consequently, the subsequent ratification by the Bar Council could not validate the purported acceptance of Simy's resignation.
The Division Bench also considered the Single Judge's observations regarding the Bar Council's conduct in producing documents before the writ court.
During the proceedings, the Bar Council had maintained that two communications dated January 8, 2026, had been sent to Simy. The writ petitioner, Simy has disputed the correctness of the said submission in the reply affidavit as well as the amended writ petitions.
However, in the writ appeals, the Bar Council admitted that these communications had never actually been dispatched. It explained that the documents had been drafted but withheld pending a decision by the Bar Council and were subsequently mistakenly produced along with its counter-affidavit.
The Division Bench observed that the subsequent clarification could, at best, dislodge the finding of dishonest or fraudulent conduct. It could not completely absolve the Bar Council of responsibility for its conduct before the writ court.
“Noble though the intentions of the Bar Council of Kerala may be, in offering this explanation for their conduct before the writ court, we are of the view that their subsequent clarification of facts can at best come to their aid in dislodging only a finding of dishonest or fraudulent conduct.” the Court remarked.
Taking into account the responsibility expected of a statutory regulatory body representing the legal profession in Kerala, the Court held that the conduct would still qualify as negligence or recklessness.
On the assurance given by the Bar Council's senior counsel that there was no dishonest intention, the Bench modified the Single Judge's findings by replacing the attribution of fraudulent conduct with negligence and recklessness.
The rest of the Single Judge's findings on the issue were affirmed.
The Bench also rejected Hari Babu's contention that his appointment as Secretary would remain unaffected because the Single Judge had not separately issued an order specifically quashing his appointment.
The Court noted that Simy had challenged his appointment in the writ petition and that the Single Judge, through an interim order dated April 22, 2026, had expressly made the appointment subject to the final outcome of the proceedings.
The interim order had further clarified that if the writ petition was ultimately allowed, Hari Babu would have to vacate the post.
Since there was no challenge to that interim order, the Division Bench declined to accept the argument that his appointment remained unaffected by the findings in favour of Simy.
The Court thus dismissed both writ appeals as devoid of merit, subject to the limited modification of the Single Judge's findings concerning the Bar Council's conduct.
Counsel for Appellant in W.A 1882/ 2026: P. Ravindran (Sr.), Lakshmi Ramadas, M.R. Sabu, Aparna Rajan, Sreedhar Ravindran, Fathima Parveen P.S
Counsel for Appellants in W.A 2234/ 2026: Elvin Peter P.J (Sr.),K.R. Ganesh, Reshma Prakash Kurian, Adarsh Babu C.S
Counsel for Respondent: Renjith Thampan (Sr.), , Jaisankar V. Nair, Arathi Karunakaran, Cristy Therasa Suresh