Kerala High Court Disposes Of PILs Challenging State Waqf Board's Composition After Its Reconstitution
| Challenge to reconstituted Waqf Board must be raised in fresh proceedings, Court said.
The Kerala High Court on Thursday (November 19) disposed of the public interest litigations (PILs) filed challenging the constitution of the State Waqf Board. [2026 LiveLaw (Ker) 540]
The Division Bench of Chief Justice Soumen Sen and Justice Syam Kumar V.M. noted that the State government has reconstituted the Waqf Board on October 16 and observed that if any grievance is there with respect to the reconstituted, it should be raised in separate proceedings:
"In view of the fact that the Board has now been reconstituted, any grievance may be adjudicated in separate proceedings. PILs disposed of."
When the matter came up yesterday, Senior Advocate Santhosh Mathew argued that the PIL filed on behalf of his client, Shone George, still survives since the posts of two non-Muslim still remained vacant even after the reconstitution. However, the Bench was of the opinion that separate proceedings have to be initiated in view of the reconstitution of the Board.
"Our limited issue was find to out whether the constitution of the Board was proper or not...In the reconstituted Board, if these two are not there, then that has to be done by the State. Now that reconstitution is done, you will be at liberty to approach the learned Single Judge. You file a fresh plea," Justice Sen orally said.
The senior counsel then submitted that since his client is a public interest litigant, a fresh PIL may be filed to address the grievance raised.
The Court was also informed about the filing of two writ petitions challenging the government order reconstituting the Board. It was further informed that the Single Judge, before whom the afore writ petitions have been instituted, had referred the cases before the Bench hearing the PILs and that the reference order itself has been challenged before another Division Bench.
Considering the submission, the Court observed that the causes of action in the PILs and the writ petitions filed before the Single Judge are different. It added:
"The issue before the learned Single Judge was regarding the reconstitution of the Waqf Board and we are not in seisin of that matter. In view thereof, the reconstitution of the Waqf Board has resulted in a fresh cause of action and for which the aggrieved parties have filed the respective writ petitions. In view thereof, the writ petitions are required to be heard by the learned SJ as per roster...The observation made by us with regard to the matter being taken up by the learned Single Judge is only clarificatory of our order on which reliance was placed by the learned Single Judge and is not on the merits of the order passed by the learned Single Judge."
Thus, it disposed of the PILs.
Background
All the PILs have challenged the non-inclusion of non-Muslim persons to the Board, which is mandated as per the newly amended Waqf Act.
One of the PILs, moved by the Christian charitable organisation named Assembly of Christian Trust Services (ACTS), has also challenged the upload of the details of the disputed Munambam land on UMEED Portal (Unified Waqf Management, Empowerment, Efficiency, and Development Portal), which is set up for the purpose of filing of details of waqf, saying that it affects Hindu and Christian communities living there.
In the PIL moved by ACTS, there is a challenge to the very composition of the Board for non-inclusion of Shia, Bohra and Aghakhani communities as mandated by law. The composition is also challenged on various other grounds.
The organisation has thus sought for a direction to the State government to issue a fresh notification nominating new members to the Board in accordance with law within a timeframe fixed by the Court. The ACTS has also challenged the filing of the disputed Munambam land by the Board on Centre's UMEED Portal on the ground that the Waqf Act empowers only the muttawali to do so.
In the PIL, moved by BJP leader Shone George, the prayer is for a direction to the State government to nominate the two non-Muslim members immediately and to declare that the Waqf Board is presently functioning in violation of Section 14(1) of the Waqf Act as amended in 2025. The Court had earlier sought the State's response and had directed it to file an affidavit.
In yet another PIL, the same grounds taken in the afore cases were also taken. Additionally, the inclusion of CPI(M) politician and former MLA Kunhammed Kutty Master in the Board is highlighted.
Counsel for the petitioners: Santhosh Mathew (Sr.), Shinto Mathew Abraham, Anil Sebastian Pulickel, Mathew Nevin Thomas, Kurian Antony Mathew, Karthik Rajagopal, Leah Rachel Ninan, Noel Ninan Ninan, Aparnna S., Adeen Nazar, Arun Joseph Mathew, Rohan Mathew, Veena Raveendran, Karthika Maria, Adil M.H., Joseph Joy, S. Sanal Kumar (Sr.), K.B. Rahim, Lakshmi Sreedhar, P.B. Krishnan (Sr.)
Counsel for the respondents: P.M.Saneer - Spl.G.P. To Addl. A.G., K. Jaju Babu - Advocate General, P. Sreekumar - ASGI, T. Krishnanunni (Sr.), Jamsheed Hafiz, Harikrishnan P.B.