Partition Act | Family Member Can Claim Right To Buy Share Of Undivided Family House Sold To Stranger Even At Execution Stage: MP High Court
The Madhya Pradesh High Court has held that a member of the undivided family can exercise the right under Section 4 of the Partition Act to purchase the share of a dwelling house transferred to a stranger, even at the stage of execution of the partition decree. [2026 LiveLaw (MP) 464]
The court observed that Section 4 can be invoked even during execution proceedings, provided the statutory requirements are satisfied.
The bench of Justice Ashish Shroti observed:
"right under Section 4 of Act of 1893 can be claimed even at the stage of execution of partition decree, the plaintiff in the instant can also be allowed to submit such an undertaking in the execution proceedings, particularly when all other ingredients for attracting Section 4 are satisfied".
The dispute concerned a double-storey house in Guna which was jointly purchased by the appellant and his real brother in 1999. In 2005, his brother sold his half share in the property to respondent no. 3, an outsider, for ₹1.20 lakh through a registered sale deed.
The appellant claimed that he was unaware of the transaction and learnt about it only in March 2012, after receiving a legal notice from the purchaser. He asserted that, as co-owner, he had a preferential right to purchase his brother's share and that it could not have been transferred to a third party without being first offered to him.
He subsequently filed a suit seeking declaration that the sale deed was null and void, along with permanent injunction restraining the purchaser from interfering with his possession. The purchaser opposed the suit and filed a counterclaim seeking declaration of ownership, partition and separate possession of the portion purchased by him
The trial court dismissed the appellant's suit and decreed the counterclaim. The First Appellate Court affirmed the decision, holding that Section 22 of the Hindu Succession Act was inapplicable because the property had been jointly purchased by brothers and had not devolved upon them through inheritance.
Before the High Court, the appellant's claim was considered under Section 4 of the Partition Act, which enables a member of an undivided family to purchase the share in a dwelling house transferred to a stranger when the transferee seeks partition.
The court observed that the provision is intended to prevent strangers from intruding into a dwelling house occupied by other members of the family and to protect their peaceful enjoyment of the common house.
In the present case, the court found that the property was a dwelling house belonging to an undivided family, the appellant and his brother each held a half share, and the brother had transferred his share to a stranger. Further, the purchaser had himself filed a counterclaim seeking partition. Thus, all requirements for invoking Section 4, except submission of undertaking to purchase the share, stood satisfied.
The court rejected the purchaser's contention that appellant could not furnish the undertaking at the second appellate stage. The court further reiterated that the right under Section 4 could be claimed even at the stage of execution of a partition decree. It was also noted that the appellant had submitted the requisite undertaking during the appeal.
The court further rejected the argument that the appellant had changed his case by invoking Section 4 at the second appellate stage. It noted that the plaint itself contained an assertion of his preferential right to purchase his brother's share. Therefore, the claim under Section 4 did not constitute a new or inconsistent stance.
The bench noted, "The respondents' counsel also contended that the plaintiff has filed a simplicitor suit challenging defendant's sale deed and, therefore, he cannot be allowed to change his stand of claiming right under Section 4 of Act of 1893 at second appellate stage. However, as noted above, the plaintiff has asserted his preferential right to purchase the property as gathered from averments made in para 4 of plaint. He has though challenged defendant's sale deed, the basis of such challenge is his preferential right of purchasing share of defendant no.1. Therefore, there is no shift of stand contrary to what is asserted in plaint".
On the scope of Section 2 of the Partition Act, the court observed that the provision makes general arrangements for partition of joint family properties among co-sharers. When read with Section 4, it was evident that Section 2 contemplates partition among co-sharers who are members of the family, and not between a family member and a stranger. Accordingly, the respondent no 2, being an outsider, was not entitled to invoke Section 2 of the Act.
In view of these circumstances, the court held that the appellant was entitled to an opportunity to purchase the share sold to respondent no. 2 under Section 4 of the Partition Act.
As execution proceedings concerning partition were still pending, the bench directed the appellant to submit his undertaking before the executing court. The executing court was directed to determine the value of the share sold to the respondent no. 2 and give the appellant an opportunity to purchase it at the valuation so determined.
Both parties would be permitted to place material before the executing court for determining the property's value.
Accordingly, the court set aside the judgment and decree of the trial court and the first appellate court and allowed the second appeal.
For Appellant: Advocate Faiz Ahmed Qureshi
For Respondent no 2: Advocates Siddharth Sijoria and Madhur Bhargava