'Can't Issue Blanket Order For Advance Notice Before Police Investigation': Madras High Court In Veeramani's Daughter's Plea Alleging Harassment
The Madras High Court, on Tuesday (November 17), orally remarked that it could not issue blanket directions to the police to give advance notice to Archana Veeramani before conducting an investigation in connection with the POCSO case involving her father and granite baron Veeramani.
Justice V Lakshminarayanan was hearing Archana's petition to quash a summons issued to her under Section 35(3) of the BNSS and to direct investigation into the alleged human rights violation.
“There cannot be a blanket order against the police to give advance notice to the petitioner and thereafter carry on the investigation activities,” the court said.
The petitioner had argued that though she had not been arrayed as an accused in the POCSO case, the SIT, which had been specially constituted by the Tamil Nadu government to probe the offence, had violated her human rights in the garb of questioning her.
The petitioner argued that when she had boarded a flight to Singapore to attend to her son who needed medical treatment, the staff deplaned her from the flight without giving any reasons or without any summons, warrant, court order, LOC or other authority. She added that she was forcibly taken to the SIT office in Egmore, where she was questioned by the SIT.
The petitioner submitted that while she was at the SIT office, she was not even permitted to use the restroom. She also submitted that she was suffering from Multiple sclerosis, which affected her central nervous system, and by 5 pm, she collapsed on the floor and lost bladder control several times. She further submitted that the police did not give her medical assessment during this time and instead recorded her on a mobile phone and video camera.
In the previous hearing, Senior Advocate Nithya Ramakrishnan, appearing for the petitioner, submitted that the notice under Section 35(3) of the BNSS was illegal as it could be served only on an accused. The State had sought time to file its response to the plea.
When the matter was taken up today, Additional Public Prosecutor Arun Anbumani requested the court to grant some more time to file the counter.
Meanwhile, Nithya Ramakrishnan informed the court that the police had recently entered the house where she was residing along with her elderly mother and started excavating the property without any information. She thus requested the court to grant some protection, directing the police to inform her 24 hours in advance before visiting her house and to permit her lawyer to be present in the future investigation.
To this, Anbumani argued that the police had not entered the house but only excavated the pool area near the house. Anbumani also informed the court that the excavation was conducted as Veeramani's driver had confessed to the police that one of the minor victims was buried in the premises. Anbumani also submitted that the excavation was carried out in the presence of an executive magistrate and that the entire process was video-recorded.
When the court asked Anbumani if the police had found anything after excavating the area, the prosecutor submitted that all details would be mentioned in the counter and requested time to file the same.
With respect to the petitioner's request for interim protection, the court said that it could not issue blanket directions to the police. However, the court said that if the police wanted to interrogate the petitioner or her mother, they could do so in the presence of their lawyer. It added that the lawyer should be away from earshot.
The court then adjourned the hearing to November 24.