The Patna HC has held that a person cannot be prosecuted under Section 7 of the Essential Commodities Act merely because he was driving a vehicle allegedly involved in the transportation of diverted Public Distribution System (PDS) foodgrains. The Court observed that where there is no evidence connecting the driver to the ownership, entrustment, sale or misappropriation of PDS stock, his status as a driver alone cannot establish criminal liability.
A Single Judge Bench of Justice Chandra Shekhar Jha quashed criminal proceedings against a tractor driver accused of involvement in the alleged diversion of PDS foodgrains, holding that the materials collected during investigation did not disclose the essential ingredients of offences under Sections 409, 420 and 120-B IPC or Section 7 of the Essential Commodities Act.
The case arose from an FIR registered on the basis of a written complaint submitted by the Block Supply Officer, Sheikhpura, alleging that PDS foodgrains had been lifted and transported to Jaishri Krishan Rice Mill. The police registered Sheikhpura (Hathiyawan O.P.) P.S. Case No. 161 of 2013 under Sections 420, 409 and 120-B IPC and Section 7 of the Essential Commodities Act.
The petitioner, Shashi Kant Kumar, contended that he was neither named in the FIR nor the owner of the rice mill. He submitted that he was merely a tractor driver and had no connection with the alleged business or diversion of foodgrains. He further relied on paragraph 50 of the case diary, which identified him only as the driver of the tractor bearing registration number BR-52-8720. However, the Sub-Divisional Judicial Magistrate, Sheikhpura, rejected his application for discharge under Section 239 CrPC. Aggrieved, he approached the High Court seeking quashing of the order and consequential criminal proceedings.
Examining the applicability of Section 7 of the Essential Commodities Act, the High Court relied on its earlier decision in Arvind Kumar v. State of Bihar, Cr. Misc. No. 21936 of 2011, which had held:
“It has been settled by several decisions of this Court that no prosecution under the Essential Commodities Act could be launched as against a private person. The petitioner, admittedly, is not a dealer under the Public Distribution System.”
Applying this principle, the Court observed that the petitioner's position was distinguishable because the investigation identified him only as a tractor driver. It noted that there was no material suggesting that he was a PDS dealer, agent, owner of the rice mill or a person entrusted with the PDS stock. Consequently, the Court held that the essential foundation for prosecuting him under Section 7 of the Essential Commodities Act was absent.
The Bench also examined whether the allegations established criminal breach of trust or cheating under Sections 409 and 420 IPC. Referring to the Supreme Court's judgment in N. Raghavender v. State of Andhra Pradesh, CBI, (2021) 18 SCC 70, the Court reiterated that entrustment of property and dishonest misappropriation are essential ingredients of Section 409 IPC, while deception, dishonest inducement and the requisite criminal intention are necessary for an offence under Section 420 IPC.
The Court found no material suggesting that the petitioner had been entrusted with PDS foodgrains or had dishonestly misappropriated them. There was also no allegation that he had deceived or dishonestly induced anyone.
On the allegation of criminal conspiracy under Section 120-B IPC, the Court observed:
“In the present case, there is no material showing any prior meeting of minds or agreement between the petitioner and the other accused persons for committing the alleged offences. His alleged connection with the occurrence rests essentially upon his status as a driver. Such circumstance, by itself, cannot constitute the ingredients of criminal conspiracy.”
The Court concluded that the petitioner's mere association with the vehicle could not substitute for evidence establishing the statutory ingredients of the alleged offences. It held:
“Tested on the aforesaid principles, this Court finds that the materials available against the petitioner do not disclose the basic ingredients of Sections 409, 420 or 120-B of the IPC. The petitioner is admittedly reflected in paragraph 50 of the case diary as the driver of the tractor and there is no material indicating his entrustment with the P.D.S. stock, dishonest misappropriation, deception, inducement or participation in any conspiracy.”
Holding that continuation of the criminal proceedings would amount to an abuse of the process of the Court, the High Court allowed the petition and quashed the impugned discharge order and all consequential proceedings insofar as they concerned the petitioner.
Appearance:
For the Petitioner: Mr. Pramod Kumar, Advocate
For the Opposite Party: Mr. Surendra Kumar, Additional Public Prosecutor