Installing CCTV/ Ownership Board On Disputed Property Not 'Prima Facie' Violation Of Court's 'No Coercive Steps' Order: Telangana High Court
The Telangana High Court dismissed a contempt plea filed by a Church against two persons for allegedly violated an interim order directing no coercive steps against the Church by installing CCTV cameras and erecting an ownership board near the church premises.
The court said that the alleged acts did not prima facie amount to 'coercive steps' as the installation was made on a property adjacent to the Church which the respondents claimed was owned by them to protect it from anti-social elements and prevent encroachment. It also said that such an action did not prima facie amount to demolition or dispossession and thus could not be categorized as coercive step.
Justice G.M. Mohiuddin held that the dispute between the church and the private respondents over the location of the impugned installations primarily involved boundary and title questions. Such issues cannot be adjudicated in summary contempt proceedings, the court noted.
“…For an act to constitute civil contempt, there must be wilful and deliberate disobedience of the order of the Court. The respondents have stated in their counter-affidavit that they installed the CCTV cameras and erected the board with a view to protecting their property from anti-social elements and preventing encroachment. Even if the respondents are mistaken in their understanding of their legal rights, there is no clear material on record to establish that their actions were intended to wilfully disobey the orders of this Court or undermine its authority…”, the court observed.
To recap, the church had alleged that during the pendency of a previous writ petition and a subsisting interim order in its favour, the respondents installed two CCTV cameras on the beam of the church, and erected a board on the compound wall, claiming ownership over the property. After a legal notice was issued to the two respondents in October 2020, they replied that they were entitled to do so as the actual owners of the plot in dispute.
According to the church, these acts were equivalent to 'coercive steps' that violated the interim order, and hence the contempt plea was filed
The court, however, said that the term 'coercive steps' in the context of the writ petition referred to actions taken to dispossess the church, demolish the structure, or otherwise interfere with its possession and rights.
“….The interim order was primarily intended to restrain the respondents from demolishing the church or taking coercive action in relation to its property pending disposal of the writ petition. The installation of CCTV cameras and erection of a board by the respondents, who claim to be the owners of the adjacent property, would not prima facie, amount to coercive steps against the church in the nature of dispossession or demolition…”, the court underscored.
Under the impression that their impugned actions have constituted contempt, the respondents have also tendered an unconditional apology, the court pointed out.
“…Determination of the present dispute would require examination of the relevant title documents and proper identification and demarcation of the respective properties. Such an exercise would go beyond the limited scope of the present contempt proceedings. Although the petitioner has sought appointment of an Advocate Commissioner to ascertain the location of the CCTV cameras, the Court is not inclined to convert the contempt proceedings into an independent exercise for adjudication of the disputed property boundaries…”, the court added further.
Hence, the court held that the petitioner had failed to establish that the respondents wilfully disobeyed the interim order dated April 11, 2018.
For context, the petitioner church had in the original writ plea challenged a 2017 letter by he Greater Hyderabad Municipal Corporation, asking it to hand over its property for road widening and flyover construction. Along with that, the church also pushed for realignment of the flyover plan, stating that other similarly placed religious structures along the route was exempted.
In December 2017, the High Court restrained the respondents from taking 'coercive steps' against the church. The order was extended from time to time, including in April, until further orders. Private Respondents, impleaded as R4 & R5 in the original writ petition back in 2018 are the respondents in the contempt plea.
As per the respondents, the portion of land including the disputed property was purchased by their mother in 1964 through a registered sale deed. Upon her demise in 2004, the respondents argued that the property became theirs. According to them, the interim order in the writ petition, before their impleadment, was only against coercive steps that could be taken by the official respondent state authorities.
However, the court rejected the respondents' contention that the interim order was not operative against them, since the interim order was extended after they joined the plea as respondents, and the directive issued by the court specifically was that 'no one should take coercive steps against the petitioner church', be it official or unofficial respondents.
“…. The interim order was primarily intended to restrain the respondents from demolishing the church or taking coercive action in relation to its property pending disposal of the writ petition. The installation of CCTV cameras and erection of a board by the respondents, who claim to be the owners of the adjacent property, would not prima facie, amount to coercive steps against the church in the nature of dispossession or demolition… The main dispute between the parties concerns the precise location of the CCTV cameras and the board…”, the court underscored.
Accordingly, the contempt case was dismissed.
Advocate J. Sudheer appeared for the church and Advocate Praveen Kumar Challa appeared for the respondents.