Investor Firm's CFO Cannot Be Implicated In Company's Alleged Fraud Merely Due To Association: Telangana High Court
Granting anticipatory bail to investment advisory entity Accel India Management LLP's CFO Amit Jhunjhunwala booked in the alleged Bizongo-TradeCred 'Scam', Telangana High Court said that his "mere association" with Accel which had invested in Bizongo, did not establish his involvement in the alleged offences committed through Bizongo.For context, Bizongo is a vendor digitization platform...
Granting anticipatory bail to investment advisory entity Accel India Management LLP's CFO Amit Jhunjhunwala booked in the alleged Bizongo-TradeCred 'Scam', Telangana High Court said that his "mere association" with Accel which had invested in Bizongo, did not establish his involvement in the alleged offences committed through Bizongo.
For context, Bizongo is a vendor digitization platform which provides supply chain financing. TradeCred is an alternative debt and short-term credit platform.
A registered investor on the TradeCred platform claimed that he parted with Rs 46.6 lakhs in invoice receivables of Bizongo through five offers for sale, and multiple purchase confirmations, executed in July 2024. Complainant claimed that amount remained unpaid, despite expiry of the repayment period and issuance of balance liability confirmations and repayment proposals.
The complainant had alleged false and misleading information, double discounting of invoices, and diversion of funds, causing losses to him as well as to more than 700 other investors.
Jhunjhunwala was booked in a case over allegations of double discounting, diversion of funds and non-repayment of invested funds on TradeCred Platform.
The single judge bench of Justice N Tukaramji said:
“…The petitioner contends that he is the Chief Financial Officer of Accel India Management LLP and neither a Director nor an employee of Smartpaddle Technology Private Limited (Bizongo), and had no direct control over its operations, bank accounts, treasury or financial transactions. Though these contentions require investigation, his precise association with the alleged transactions and the extent of his authority are relevant in assessing the necessity of his arrest. Mere association with an investment advisory entity which had invested in Bizongo does not, by itself, establish his involvement in the alleged offences…”, the court noted in the order.
The CFO was arrayed as Accused No. 2 in an FIR registered at Madhura Nagar Police Station, Hyderabad, for offences under Sections 316(5)(Criminal Breach of Trust by Public Servant or Banker, etc.) , 318(4)(cheating), 61(2) (Criminal conspiracy) read with Section 3(5) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023.
Before the High Court, Senior Counsel E. Uma Maheshwar Rao for the petitioner had submitted that Accel India is an investment advisory firm, and Accel Mauritius, a separate legal entity, had invested approximately Rs. 90 crores in Bizongo. The petitioner was never a director, employee or key managerial personnel of Bizongo, and neither had any control over invoice discounting, repayment decisions, bank accounts or official records, the court was told.
The court was also told by the CFO that he had no involvement in the exercise of onboarding TradeCred, uploading invoices, managing escrow accounts or controlling the fund flow.
The prosecution opposed the bail, submitting that the complainant had invested substantial amounts but was not repaid. According to the prosecution, the statement of a TradeCred representative allegedly confirmed the outstanding amount and implicated the CFO, claiming that Bizongo had received approximately Rs. 223 crores from customers against discounted invoices but transferred only Rs. 99 crores, while allegedly transferring Rs. 24 crore and Rs. 71 crores to two related parties between October 2024 and April 2025. The statement further alleged that the petitioner CFO participated in discussions concerning utilisation of funds and opposed the use of such funds for repayment to buyers.
“…The prosecution principally relies upon the statement of the TradeCred representative, who allegedly attributed to the petitioner participation in discussions concerning the utilisation of funds and repayment to investors. While this allegation requires investigation, the petitioner's precise role, decision-making authority and involvement in the alleged diversion of funds remain matters for further examination. The material presently placed before this Court does not establish that custodial interrogation is indispensable for the progress of the investigation. The investigation substantially concerns invoices, bank statements, financial records and electronic communications, which can ordinarily be secured and examined by the Investigating Agency…”, the Court, after hearing both sides, noted.
The other criminal cases allegedly registered against the CFO in different States could be relevant to assessing his antecedents, but their mere registration, without examining their nature, status and outcome, wouldn't be establishing his involvement in the present offence, the court added.
Accordingly, the anticipatory bail plea was allowed subjected to conditions.