Employer Cannot Deny Gratuity To Long-Serving Ad Hoc Employee; Such Employee Is Deemed Regular For Retiral Benefits: Tripura High Court
The Tripura High Court has held that an employee who has rendered nearly 33 years of continuous service cannot be treated as an ad hoc employee to deny retiral benefits.
The Court observed that for the purpose of retirement benefits, such an employee must be treated as a regular employee, directing the Tripura Horticulture Corporation Limited to pay ₹20 lakh as gratuity along with 7% annual interest.
Division Bench of Chief Justice Mr. M.S. Ramachandra Rao and Justice S. Datta Purkayastha remarked that: “The respondent no.1 cannot be treated as a temporary and ad hoc employee after his services were utilised from 17.11.1988 till 31.8.2021, and for purposes of retiral benefits he has to be treated as if he is a regular employee.”
The respondent, Ratan Kumar Biswas, joined the Tripura Horticulture Corporation Limited (THCL) as a Driver on November 17, 1988, and retired on August 31, 2021, after nearly 33 years of service. Following his retirement, he sought ₹20 lakh as gratuity under Section 4(3) of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972, along with leave encashment and interest.
However, the Corporation rejected his claims, contending that he had been appointed on an ad hoc basis and that no records of his regularisation were available. The Single Judge allowed his writ petition, prompting the State and the Corporation to challenge the decision before the Division Bench.
The Court held that an employee cannot be denied retiral benefits merely because his appointment was initially ad hoc after the employer had continuously utilised his services for nearly 33 years.
The Court observed that Biswas must be treated as a regular employee for the limited purpose of retiral benefits, particularly since THCL had also granted him CAS and ACP benefits during his service.
The Court further held that Biswas was entitled to gratuity of ₹20 lakh under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972, noting that THCL had extended the same benefit to similarly placed employees. However, it denied leave encashment as the Corporation had no provision for granting such benefit to its employees.
Date of Decision: 18.11.2026