Click the Play button to listen to article

The Bombay High Court has granted an ex parte ad-interim injunction restraining a former employee of Gerson Lehrman Group India Private Limited (GLG India) and his competing business from using, disclosing or commercially exploiting the company's identified confidential and proprietary information. The Court has also appointed the Court Receiver, assisted by an independent forensic expert, to preserve relevant electronic evidence in proceedings under Section 9 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.

Justice Amit Borkar passed the order on September 3 in an arbitration petition filed by GLG India against its former Senior Associate, Kevin Thadathil Mathew, and Agnios Private Limited, a company incorporated by him.

Background

Mathew joined GLG India as a Senior Associate in January 2025 and executed an employment contract and a confidentiality and non-disclosure agreement. Agnios Private Limited was incorporated by him in January 2026, while he was still employed with GLG India. The company subsequently alleged that Agnios was carrying on a competing expert-network business.

The petition stated that shortly before Mathew's last working day on May 19, 2026, substantial quantities of corporate information were transferred to personal cloud storage and email accounts.

A forensic report prepared by Control Risks India Private Limited recorded 387 Google Drive upload records, a synchronisation operation involving 224 corporate OneDrive files and the transfer of an approximately 334 MB ZIP archive to personal storage. The forensic comparison also identified 155 unique files matching GLG India's corporate data by filename and/or file hash.

The material was stated to include client contracts, expert databases, pricing information, commercial arrangements, internal research methodologies and confidential client-project information. GLG India apprehended that the information could be used to give the competing business an unlawful commercial advantage.

Court's Observations

The Court observed that the employment contract and non-disclosure agreement prima facie established continuing confidentiality obligations, which did not come to an end with the cessation of employment.

It found that the forensic material identified transfers involving particular dates, times, destination accounts and files stated to correspond with the company's corporate data. The Court held that GLG India had made out a prima facie case for preservation of the identified electronic material.

However, the Court cautioned that the forensic exercise could not become an unrestricted search into the private digital life of the former employee.

It observed that unrestricted access to personal devices, email accounts, WhatsApp, ChatGPT, Google Gemini and other AI or large language model accounts could expose substantial personal information unrelated to the dispute. Such relief would be excessive and disproportionate at the ex parte stage.

The Court clarified that whether the respondents had used the transferred information for the competing business, whether any third party had received it and the extent of any alleged misuse would have to be considered after the respondents were served and heard.

Directions

The Court restrained the respondents and persons acting through them from accessing, retaining, copying, reproducing, using, transmitting, sharing, disclosing, disseminating, publishing or commercially exploiting GLG India's confidential and proprietary information identified in the petition. They were also restrained from permitting third parties to access or exploit such information or using it to carry on or assist a competing business.

The Court Receiver, Bombay High Court, was appointed to undertake a limited preservation exercise with the assistance of an independent forensic expert. The exercise is confined to identifying and preserving devices, repositories and electronic material reasonably connected with the transfers identified in the forensic report and the company's information.

The expert has been directed to maintain appropriate forensic safeguards, including hash values and chain-of-custody records, and submit a report to the Court in a sealed cover.

The Court further directed that personal, privileged and unrelated information be segregated, as far as practicable, and not disclosed to the petitioner without further orders. The respondents' personal devices are not to be taken into permanent custody at this stage, and unrestricted access to their personal accounts has not been permitted.

The respondents have also been directed to preserve relevant electronic and physical records and not delete, destroy, alter, conceal or transfer any material that may contain or relate to the petitioner's confidential and proprietary information.

The Court kept wider reliefs, including unrestricted access to personal devices and accounts and a comprehensive forensic examination beyond the limited preservation exercise, open for consideration after notice to the respondents.

Advocates Hiten Kamod and Prem Khullar appeared for GLG India, along with Rushil Mathur, Amrita Natarajan and Ashley Dsouza, instructed by Mayur Shetty and Kochhar & Co.

Tags: