Bombay High Court Grants Interim Protection To Sarla Advantech In Trade Secrets Dispute; Holds Arbitration Agreement Prima Facie Exists
The Bombay High Court has granted interim protection to Sarla Advantech Private Limited against the alleged misuse of its confidential and proprietary business information by its former Managing Director and CEO, Anil Mehta, and Percivon Technologies Private Limited.
Justice Amit Borkar, while partly allowing a petition under Section 9 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, rejected Mehta's preliminary objection regarding maintainability. The Court held that sufficient material existed, prima facie, to show that the arbitration agreement contained in the 1998 employment terms continued to govern the dispute, while clarifying that the finding would not bind the Arbitral Tribunal under Section 16 of the Act.
Background
Sarla Advantech alleged that Mehta and several former employees who subsequently joined Percivon Technologies had misused its confidential business information, including technical documents, rate charts, costing sheets, supplier details and proprietary project case studies, to solicit clients and undertake competing business activities.
The company also alleged that confidential files had been transferred from official email accounts to personal accounts and that its proprietary case studies were used in presentations made by Percivon Technologies.
The company had earlier obtained an ex parte ad interim order on June 27, 2025, restraining the respondents from using its confidential information and appointing a Court Receiver to secure electronic devices and preserve digital evidence.
Court's Observations
Mehta contended that his employment agreement dated September 21, 2017, did not contain an arbitration clause and that the earlier employment terms dated August 20, 1998, had ceased to operate.
The Court noted that Clause 21 of the 1998 employment terms contained an arbitration agreement. It also observed that Clause 2.2 of the 2017 agreement preserved Mehta's original date of joining as August 1, 1998, along with his accrued service benefits, indicating continuity of employment.
The Court further relied on an email dated August 24, 2017, sent by Mehta to employees, stating that their roles, responsibilities and employment terms would remain unchanged following the business transfer.
It held that execution of a fresh employment agreement did not automatically mean that all earlier contractual obligations, including the arbitration agreement, had come to an end. However, the question of whether the arbitration agreement had survived would require fuller examination by the Arbitral Tribunal.
Rejecting the allegation that the company had obtained the earlier interim order using a fabricated termination letter, the Court observed that such a serious issue could not be conclusively determined on affidavit evidence without proper evidence and a full trial.
Interim Protection
The Court restrained Mehta and Percivon Technologies from disclosing, copying, using, transmitting or commercially exploiting Sarla Advantech's confidential and proprietary information. They were also restrained from carrying on business activities using the company's confidential information or trade secrets.
The Court Receiver appointed under the June 27, 2025 order was directed to continue preserving the electronic devices, documents, mirror images and digital evidence already secured.
Further, Mehta and Percivon Technologies were directed to:
Preserve all electronic devices and digital storage media containing the company's information.
File an affidavit within four weeks disclosing such devices and whether copies of the information had been transferred to third parties.
Furnish, within six weeks, details of projects, if any, executed using the company's confidential or proprietary information.
The Court kept open the company's prayer for deposit of alleged profits for consideration by the Arbitral Tribunal after evidence is led. It rejected the prayer for a blanket restraint against alienation of the respondents' assets, finding no prima facie material indicating an attempt to defeat a future award.
Clarifying that its observations were only prima facie and would not bind subsequent proceedings, the Court partly allowed the arbitration petition, with no order as to costs.
Appearances
Advocate Aadil Parsurampuria, along with Rushil Mathur, Yash Pitroda, Amrita Natarajan and Mayur Setty, instructed by Kochhar & Co., appeared for Sarla Advantech Private Limited.
Advocate Karl Tamboly, along with Ryan D'Souza, Vikrantsingh Negi, Ekta Tyagi, Priyamvada Singhania, Sneha Barange, Aishwarya Pawar and Shreedhar Joshi, instructed by DSK Legal, appeared for Anil Mehta.