Click the Play button to listen to article

The Madras High Court has set aside an order of the Indian Patent Office refusing a patent application filed by Aventose Energy Private Limited and directed the Patent Office to grant the patent.

Justice K. Kumaresh Babu allowed the civil miscellaneous appeal filed under Section 117A of the Patents Act, 1970, challenging the refusal order dated October 20, 2023, passed by the Assistant Controller of Patents and Designs, Chennai.

The patent application (No. 202141019671), titled “System and Method for Operating Automobiles with an Electric Drivetrain”, relates to an electric vehicle system configured to detect a predefined set of events, including vehicle faults affecting its performance, and activate a safe mode of operation to protect passengers as well as the vehicle.

Background

The Controller had rejected the patent application by relying on four prior-art documents, D1 to D4, holding that the claimed invention lacked novelty and inventive step and fell within the realm of common general knowledge.

Aggrieved by the refusal, Aventose Energy approached the High Court under Section 117A of the Patents Act.

Submissions Of The Appellant

Appearing for Aventose Energy, Advocate S. Eshwar submitted that the First Examination Report (FER) had accepted the novelty of the invention. However, the impugned refusal order subsequently held that the invention lacked novelty without providing the applicant an opportunity to address that objection.

He further argued that the Controller had confused the principles of novelty and inventive step. Although four prior-art documents had been cited, D2 alone had been identified as the closest prior art. The Controller had failed to adequately analyse the appellant's claims vis-à-vis the cited documents.

Comparing the claims with D2, the counsel submitted that several features of the claimed invention were absent from the prior-art document and that the claims were materially different. He also contended that the Controller had merely extracted the claims and the prior-art document without assigning reasons for concluding that the invention incorporated the technical features of D2 along with common general knowledge.

It was further argued that the Controller had failed to identify what constituted such common general knowledge as on the date of filing the patent application. The appellant also pointed out that, despite pressing the Controller to address the other requirements, no opportunity had been provided to do so.

Submissions Of The Respondent

Opposing the appeal, the respondent submitted that the Controller had compared the appellant's claims with prior-art document D2 and reasonably concluded that the claimed features were already available in the said document.

It was further argued that common general knowledge was explicit in D2 and that the invention was neither novel nor inventive, falling within the scope of Section 2(1)(j) of the Patents Act.

The respondent maintained that the findings and reasoning in the impugned order could not be termed an arbitrary exercise of power warranting interference by the High Court.

Findings Of The Court

After considering the submissions and examining the materials on record, the Court noted that the appellant's invention related to an electric drivetrain automobile that activates safe mode operation upon detecting a vehicle fault affecting its performance.

The Court observed that although the Controller had relied on prior-art documents D1 to D4, the findings and reasoning in the refusal order did not refer to D1. Instead, comparisons had been made with D2, D3 and D4.

Examining D3, the Court observed that it related to fault diagnosis during the discharging of a power storage system to prevent wastage of power. It dealt with the diagnosis of an electric component when the vehicle and an external power supply could be electrically coupled through a coupling unit.

The Court noted that this did not relate to the primary object of the appellant's invention, namely, activating safe mode operation while the vehicle was on the move when a defect was detected.

With respect to D2, the Court observed that the document dealt with determining whether the vehicle's system status was within a predetermined safe operating range. In contrast, the appellant's claimed invention involved detecting a failure in the vehicle system itself during its operation and activating safe mode.

The Court also examined D4 and observed that it disclosed the concept of range extension in electric vehicles, which had no relationship or similarity with the invention claimed by the appellant.

The Court further noted that D2 had been primarily identified by the Controller as the closest prior-art document. However, no reasons had been assigned for considering the other prior-art documents D1, D3 and D4.

On examining D2, the Court observed that the document disclosed a system for determining whether the vehicle's system status was within a predetermined safe operating range. The appellant's invention, on the other hand, included a user controller module to extend the operating range of the electric vehicle, thereby preventing the rider from being stranded.

The Court observed that the Controller had failed to take note of this aspect while examining the patent application.

Holding that even D2, which had been identified as the closest prior art, could not justify the rejection of the patent application, the Court found grounds to interfere with the impugned order.

Decision

Allowing the appeal, the Court set aside the refusal order and directed the Assistant Controller of Patents and Designs to grant and approve the patent to Aventose Energy Private Limited and pass appropriate orders in accordance with law.

The Court made no order as to costs.

Tags: