Every typical Instagram user is likely to stumble across an influencer marketing a skincare product, a fitness supplement or a financial app within the first few seconds of scrolling on any given day. Look very closely and you may come across two little words in pale gray text above the post: "Paid Partnership." If you blink, you'll miss it. Swipe and it's gone.

There are guidelines, that are made, amended, and circulated. But what's there instead, is something so devious: a disclosure setup based on words that are all qual, when what's really needed are words that are all quat.

Regulatory Landscape

India's mechanisms for enforcing influencer advertising disclosure have largely been constructed through two non-legislative platforms: In 2021, the Advertising Standards Council of India (ASCI) laid out guidelines for influencer advertising. These regulations expect content creators to disclose advertising relationships with brands when content is paid for, adjourning them prominently and at the start of a clip with labels like “Ad”, “Sponsored” or “Paid Partnership”. The Guidelines for Prevention of Misleading Advertisements and Endorsements 2022 of the Central Consumer Protection Authority (CCPA) have come into force this year, which require that the endorsers should be truthful and should endorse solely those goods which they have tested.

India had a separate set of rules recognizing influencer marketing as a commercial communication. On top of that, the rules more exactly pointed out that there is a disclosure obligation for commercials on social media. Lastly, ASCI had started keeping an eye on social media posts and issuing notices to influencers with commercial intent that did not have disclose. Still, the very surveillance ASCI conducted exposed this simple design flaw. What most of the breaches that ASCI saw was not people overwhelming the system, but influencers taking advantage of Instagram's Paid Partnership badge, placing, and styling endorser labels in a milieu of hashtags, or designing and positioning endorser labels so that the audience had to scroll right past them. Or in other words, they were not breaking the rules and in fact, they were breaking the rules.

The system has created a perception of a disclosure standard without the actuality of one.

Vagueness as a Structural Failure

The real problem with India's influencer disclosure system is not that it doesn't have rules it's that the rules it has, cannot be measured, measured, and enforced fairly. Disclosures should be deemed "prominent" and "upfront" based to the ASCI Influencer Advertising Guidelines 2021. As stipulated to the CCPA Guidelines 2022, endorsements must to be "clear" and "honest". These are definitely qualitative norms, and despite how strong they may be, qualitative standards are intrinsically inadequate as means of enforcement. Without a strict statutory comparison, a regulator receiving a complaint about an inadequate disclosure cannot determine whether a post is compliant or not. Furthermore, this uncertainty might be a blank check for dishonest non-compliance, making it more than just inconvenient.

Think about what the current requirements don't say. It doesn't include a minimum font size for the disclosure in a static post. It doesn't mandate where the placement of the disclosure should be (above the content, in the first line of the caption, or overlaid on the content itself). It doesn't establish a minimum length for how long the disclosure must stay visible in video, Reel or Stories. In a video or audio post, it is not essential to say it out loud. It doesn't take into consideration the disclosure's language. For instance, would an English "Ad" label be acceptable as a disclosure for a vernacular-language video that is sent to viewers in rural Tamil Nadu or Maharashtra who are unlikely to understand the term? It fails to distinguish between content forms that serve totally distinct purposes, such as a static post that a user may view for as long as they like, an Instagram Story that expires in a day, or a reel that the majority of viewers will quickly watch just once.

Seller disclosures when talking about e-commerce are provided in the Consumer Protection (E-Commerce) Rules 2020, promoted influencer content is not treated differently. In India's influencer marketing ecosystem, a platform-created, "Paid Partnership" badge that appears in small gray font just above an Instagram post, is often not noticed by the user within seconds, and is completely lacking in Stories has mostly (and for now) become the norm, all thanks to the lack of a more rigorous legislative requirement.

Pharmaceutical Advertising Contrast

The vagueness of India's influencer disclosure standards becomes particularly difficult to justify when placed alongside how Indian law approaches disclosure obligations in other regulated advertising contexts.

The (Objectionable Advertisements) Act 1954, and the rules prescribed lay down clear, quantifiable criteria for the content of pharma and health related advertisements how big the disclaimer must be, where it should be placed vis-a-vis other text, in what language it should be printed. An ad for cough syrup, for instance, should have a disclaimer that is of a certain minimum size and placed in such a way that it cannot be missed. These are not the ask for a designer to be 'creative' they are clear and objective criteria for compliance.

A celebrity who has five million Instagram followers endorses a fairness cream that makes consumers' purchasing decisions and makes included health and lifestyle claims, and that sees a much broader range of consumers than an average quarter page newspaper advertisement for a heavily regulated pharmaceutical product is comparatively much less tightly governed by disclosure regulations than the quarter page newspaper advert for the same product. This reveals that legislative delay rather than policy issues is the reason for the discrepancy, which is hard to justify under consumer protection legislation.

And, every body of behavioural research into advertising and consumer decision-making commonly finds that consumers, when they know the information is sponsored, think, and evaluate differently from when they know the information is not. So, the omission to reveal the promotional nature of influencer messaging is not simply a regulatory breach from a regulatory point of view it's a distortion of consumer decision-making that impacts the millions of Indians watching influencer videos, believing that they are being offered personal recommendations instead of paid commercial promotions. A standard that cannot ensure that this distinction is present so that a consumer will notice it, and remember it, cannot ensure the consumer is protected.

Three Levels of Harm

The consequences of vague disclosure standards operate simultaneously at the consumer, regulatory, and industry level.

At the consumer level, the lack of clear and prominent disclosure means that a significant proportion of Indian social media users will view sponsored content without ever recognising it as an advert. The 'Paid Partnership' label that forms the crux of the industry standard is a practically invisible mechanism for almost all users, small font, fleetingly visible, and often located in an area on the screen that the viewer's eye does not necessarily enter before watching the featured piece of content. Consumers who buy products based on what they believe to be genuine user advice, but in reality, are commercially incentivised endorsements, are being misled in the same way as consumers who buy products based on outright falsehoods through systemic transparency failures that the current regulatory system enables.

At the regulatory level, the lack of clarity in our current standard results in paralysis of enforcement. When ASCI or CCPA are faced with complaints that content is not disclosed adequately, the lack of any clear statutory standard enables brands and influencers to claim that a passing line, small font, or fleeting platform badge is all that's required to comply. Without any specific standard to compare to, regulators have no choice but to adjudge individual disclosures on a subjective basis.

This blurred definition produces a structurally unfair competitive field at industry level. Influencers and brands, which make an effort to develop truthful, salient, and format-appropriate disclosures face a disadvantage, by contrast with competitors who are able to take advantage of the standard's vagueness to preserve the commercial value of supposedly organic content. This has broader consequences than simply damaging the interests of individual consumers it undermines the credibility of the creator economy itself, damaging the very confidence that renders influencer advertising commercially viable.

The regulatory lacuna can be bridged but only if we bridge our qualitative aspirations with quantitative prescriptions. Here are four ways in which India's influencer disclosure regulations could be made less nebulous.

First, the CCPA must introduce format-specific disclosure requirements under the Consumer Protection Act 2019 that set out an exacting and quantifiable content requirement for each content format. These will establish the minimum font size and position for static posts, the minimum time duration and position on screen for disclosures contained within video content and Reels, the minimum oral disclosure for podcasts and live streams, and the precise label, which will constitute legal compliance with disclosure in each of these formats. The subjective language of 'prominent' and 'upfront' must be replaced with objective and quantifiable criteria that will leave little room for experimentation in non-compliance.

Second, similar to platform-created labels, platforms should explicitly accept platform-created disclosures as supplemental but not exclusive disclosures, and give equal or greater reward to creator disclosures. Regulators should treat platform-created Paid Partnership (tag) as a non-statutory disclosure and acknowledge that disclosures are made by creator.

Third, contracts, between, brands, and influencers should mandate a disclosure compliance clause, creating a shared obligation for brands to ensure that the influencers they hire provide disclosures that comply with regulatory standards. The responsibility for disclosure must move from being solely on the influencer to a joint contractual and legal duty acknowledging that brands are the main commercial beneficiaries of influencer campaigns and should that means carry appropriate compliance accountability.

Fourth, the ASCI Influencer Advertising Guidelines need statutory integrity in CCPA. That is, the existing self-regulatory disclosure guideline should be legislated as clear and actionable CCPA requirements, with established and meaningful penalties for violations. The qualitative tools that ASCI has built through years of watching influencers are real regulation but regulation that needs to be codified into measurable and enforceable obligations for regulators and judiciary to use

But when Indian regulators require disclosures to be “prominent” and “upfront” without defining what that means in a fifteen-second Reel or what this means in an Instagram story that fades in twenty-four hours or what the words would be acceptable under the law in a vernacular-language video that reaches consumers who don't even speak English to tell them it's a label, they are imposing rules that look protective on paper but don't translate at all.

To the influencer and content creator community, the message is straightforward: a platform-authored badge isn't a free get-out-of-jail- card and the uncertainty in current disclosure requirements is a ticking time-bomb, not a life raft. To the brands and marketing agencies that guide the creation of this content: lack of definitive disclosure requirements doesn't make you any less responsible for the content. It just means that you won't be able to tell if you've met those requirements (let alone that you have). And, for the millions of Indians who view the content, and base their real-world purchase decisions upon it, that statutory protection from deception isn't yet in place.

And until India introduces disclosure standards that are (a) format-specific, (b) platform-sensitive, (c) language-inclusives and (d) based on objective, measurable standards, the more the law will diverge from lived experience and widen as the creator economy expands. That the "Paid Partnership" badge is not enough. Never was. And the law should finally acknowledge this.

Author is a BBA LL.B student at MAIMS, GGSIPU. Views are personal.

Tags: