The Supreme Court today reserved judgment in the All India Judges Association case with reference to the issue of enhancement in the superannuation age of District Judges to 62 years.
Upon being informed about certain States/UTs' opposition to the enhancement, the Court asked Attorney General R Venkataramani to make one last attempt to persuade the concerned authorities so that the proceedings can be closed on a good note. The States/UTs that remained to come on board were given 2 weeks to revisit the issue.
A bench comprising Chief Justice of India Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V Mohana was dealing with the All India Judges Association case, in which the Court had earlier directed all States/UTs to consider enhancing the retirement age of district judges to 61/62 years after consulting their respective High Courts.
In September, the Court was informed that most High Courts were in favor of the age enhancement, but several States/UTs were either opposing the move or remained to take a decision. The opposition of the States/UTs was stated to be rooted in 3 issues -
(i) additional burden on State exchequer(ii) "heartburn" among other employees of the State/UT, and (iii) effect on legitimate aspirations of young entrants in judicial service.
At the time, the Court had rejected the financial burden argument, opining that retaining judicial officers for a few additional years would, in fact, defer the payment of retirement benefits, pension and other retiral dues, thereby reducing the immediate financial burden. The Court said that this would be particularly beneficial for revenue-deficit States/UTs, describing the arrangement as a potential “bonanza” for them. On the "heartburn" among other employees, the Court observed that services of government employees and judicial officers could not be equated (as the latter entered service at a substantially advanced age).
Today, Senior Advocate Siddharth Bhatnagar (Amicus) informed the Court that 15 States/UTs were now in favour of enhancement, while 12 continued to oppose and 4 (Gujarat, Jharkhand, Delhi and Puducherry) sought more time to arrive at a decision. The States/UTs opposing the enhancement included Arunachal Pradesh, Goa, Haryana, Bihar, Manipur, Meghalaya, Uttar Pradesh and Rajasthan.
The Chief Justice opined that some of the States/UTs opposing the enhancement were "minor", but some required the intervention of AG Venkataramani - particularly UP and Rajasthan. Pointing to earlier hearings, Senior Advocate Vijay Hansaria submitted that sufficient leeway had been given to the States/UTs and sought a judicial order favoring enhancement of the superannuation age. He further countered the additional financial burden argument of States/UTs, claiming that at any given time, there is about 20% vacancy in judicial posts.
When a State AG cited difficulty on account of 'financial burden', Justice Bagchi said, "You are agreeable to pay pension without taking work, and increase your human resource load, and that is a burden. And secondly is legitimate expectation of the cadre. We already have so much of vacancy that the question of legitimate expectation itself is illusory. On the other hand, it's a crying demand that we have low attrition rate of judges".
The Chief Justice, in similar spirit, impressed upon the Advocate Generals of States/UTs how the institutions can benefit from the experience of seasoned officers nearing retirement (compared to an incumbent). "In the entire bargain (paying post-retirement dues to retired officer without any work and bearing expenses of incumbent officer), you lose an experienced person. Resulting in pay to new incumbent. We don't have anything against new incumbent. New blood also is to be infused. It's not that. But it's a question of 2 years service only. We will request the AG to speak to the states/UTs and convince them. We'd like to close the proceedings with a happy note", the CJI said.
Later, Advocate General for Meghalaya told the Court that the proposal was pending with the Cabinet. Likewise, Telangana AG informed that an Ordinance had been promulgated increasing the age to 62 years. Haryana AG, on the other hand, said that his instructions were to let the Court pass an appropriate order. Punjab AG said that the issue was under active consideration and sought time.
"Please don't compare civil services with judicial services", the CJI again impressed upon the states/UTs. The CJI appealed to the reluctant states/UTs to revisit the issue and come up with a constructive proposal while the Court is in the process of writing judgment.
Before the proceedings closed, Senior Advocate Vikas Singh emphasized that retirement age has to be unanimous and opposed inclusion of any condition in the judgment about mandatory suitability assessment of judicial officers by the High Court. The senior counsel said that the States/UTs already have the option of compulsory retirement of judicial officers (in case they are not found fit); therefore, every officer should not be made to go through suitability assessment when extending service till 62 years. He also claimed that some of the concerned officers eligible for elevation had retired in the meanwhile and, so, their interests may also be protected.
Likewise, Senior Advocate Jaideep Gupta sought protection of the interests of certain officers (falling in the March-September category), who were apparently neither getting pension nor salary.
Appearance: Senior Advocates Vikas Singh, Siddharth Bhatnagar and Vijay Hansaria, Attorney General R Venkataramani (for Rajasthan), Advocate Generals of States/UTs
Case Title: ALL INDIA JUDGES ASSOCIATION AND ORS. v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS., W.P.(C) No. 1022/1989