Coconut Is Classified As Oilseed, Can't Be Sold In Fruit & Vegetable Market Even After Paying User Charges: Allahabad High Court
The Allahabad High Court has held that coconut, placed under the heading “A-Agriculture” and sub-heading “III-Oilseeds” in the Schedule to the U.P. Krishi Utpadan Mandi Adhiniyam, 1964, cannot be traded in a Market Yard set apart for fruits and vegetables, and that the user charge regime introduced in 2020 makes no difference to this position.It held that a licence to trade in fruits...
The Allahabad High Court has held that coconut, placed under the heading “A-Agriculture” and sub-heading “III-Oilseeds” in the Schedule to the U.P. Krishi Utpadan Mandi Adhiniyam, 1964, cannot be traded in a Market Yard set apart for fruits and vegetables, and that the user charge regime introduced in 2020 makes no difference to this position.
It held that a licence to trade in fruits and vegetables at such a yard carries no right to trade in coconut, and that the failure of the Mandi authorities to stop a trader from dealing in coconut there for years conferred no right on him.
The bench of Justice Alok Mathur and Justice Amitabh Kumar Rai held,
“...even after the introduction of the user charge regime, trade in coconut cannot be permitted within the premises of Navin Phal Sabzi Mandi Sthal, Sahibabad (Ghaziabad) even upon payment of user charges as coconut has not been categorised as a fruit or vegetable in the Schedule appended to the Act, 1964.”
Petitioner, a wholesale trader in fruits and vegetables, was licensed by the Krishi Utpadan Mandi Samiti, Sahibabad, Ghaziabad in 2003 and had since been bringing coconut into Navin Phal Sabzi Mandi Sthal, Sahibabad without objection. After the user charge regime came in, the authorities restrained him on the ground that coconut is an oilseed and cannot be traded in a fruit and vegetable Market Yard.
He approached the High Court seeking a mandamus permitting the entry and trading of fresh or green coconut at the Mandi Sthal, and an order holding the amendment dated 30.01.1995, which brought coconut into the Schedule under oilseeds, to be ultra vires, with a direction that it be placed instead under the heading “B. Horticulture” and sub-heading “II. Fruits”.
It was pleaded that no competent authority had prohibited the entry of coconut and that an oral direction by Mandi staff could not substitute for a statutory exercise of power. The discontinuance of market fee on coconut in 2003, it was argued, neither removed it from the Schedule nor prohibited its trade, and the Government Order dated 17.09.2021 levying user charge on non-specified agricultural produce expressly included coconut.
Petitioner pleaded that coconut was traded at other Mandi Sthals under the same framework, which made the prohibition at Sahibabad selective, and that it bore on his right under Article 19(1)(g). On the classification, he relied on an extract from a publication of the Indian Council of Agricultural Research–Central Plantation Crops Research Institute, Kasaragod describing the coconut as a drupe, a type of fruit.
Counsel for the State submitted that Navin Phal-Sabzi Mandi Sthal is a specialised market where trade is permitted only in 7 notified and 77 non-notified commodities falling under fruits and vegetables, and that the petitioner remained free to trade in coconut at the designated Cereal Mandi at Ghaziabad on payment of user charges, or anywhere outside the Mandi premises.
Examining the scheme of the Act, the Court observed that a Market Area declared under Section 6 is confined to the agricultural produce specified in the notification declaring it. It held that produce enumerated in the Schedule does not acquire the character of “specified agricultural produce” until notified under Section 6 or Section 8. A notification under Section 4-A amending the Schedule, it held, does not by itself confer that status.
It observed that Coconut was brought into the Schedule on 30.01.1995, added to the list of specified agricultural produce for the Ghaziabad Market Area on 08.05.1996 and excluded from that list on 18.07.2003, after which its trade within the Market Yards was not permissible. It became permissible again only on the order dated 17.09.2021, which allowed trade in 46 commodities on payment of user charge at 1%, of which 32 were categorised as fruits and vegetables while coconut was placed under oilseeds, held the Court.
Since Navin Phal Sabzi Mandi Sthal is a fruit and vegetable Market Yard, the Court held, only the 77 commodities falling under that category could be traded there, and coconut could be traded only in a yard designated for commodities other than fruits and vegetables.
On the plea that the petitioner had traded in coconut for years without objection, the Court held,
“The petitioner-firm, at no point of time, had any legal right to trade in green coconut. However, it continued to do so as the authorities did not restrain it from carrying on such trade. Mere inaction on the part of the authorities cannot, by itself, create any right in favour of the petitioner-firm to continue trading in green coconut when such trade is otherwise not legally permissible.”
On the challenge to the 1995 notification, the Court observed that the extract relied on showed only that a drupe, a particular stage in the coconut's development, is a type of fruit, and not that coconut in its entirety is one. In ordinary commercial parlance, it observed, coconut is understood in several forms: green coconut, watery coconut, dried coconut and copra, all falling within the expression “coconut”, and green or tender coconut finds no separate mention in the Schedule.
“Accordingly, the categorisation of coconut under the heading “A-Agriculture” and the sub-heading “III-Oilseeds” cannot be held to be illegal or incorrect. Conversely, it can also be contended that coconut as a commodity in its entirety, cannot, by any stretch of the imagination, be classified as a fruit, since dried coconut and copra cannot be categorised as fruits.”
Relying on Shri Bharuch Coconut Trading Co. v. Municipal Corporation of the City of Ahmedabad and Ramavatar Budhaiprasad v. Assistant Sales Tax Officer, Akola, the Court observed that watery coconut is not a green fruit but a distinct commodity in its own right, and that entries of this kind are to be understood as persons dealing in the commodity understand them rather than in a botanical sense.
“Thus, we are of the view that the State Legislature has rightly placed coconut, as understood in common parlance, under the heading “A-Agriculture” and the sub-heading “III-Oilseeds” in the Schedule appended to the Act, 1964. Such classification cannot be said to be defective or illegal in any manner.”
Finding no want of legislative competence or violation of any fundamental right, and holding that the licence granted to the petitioner never authorised it to trade in coconut, the Court dismissed the writ petition.