The Allahabad High Court has directed the Uttar Pradesh Government to issue guidelines to ensure that the person against whom the police submit a report recommending the opening of a history sheet is given an opportunity of being heard.

The Court has also directed the State Government to provide for an annual review of history sheets so that entries against persons who have subsequently been acquitted or exonerated of criminal charges are closed and the "shadow of surveillance by police on their life and liberty gets removed".

A Bench of Justice Siddharth and Justice Vinai Kumar Dwivedi observed that the existing procedure under the U.P. Police Regulations, framed during the colonial era, did not incorporate the principles of natural justice and could expose citizens to surveillance without giving them an opportunity to contest the police report recommending the opening of a history sheet.

"It is high time that this practice should be stopped"," the Court observed while mandating that before opening a Class-A or Class-B history sheet against any citizen, they must be given one opportunity to submit their objections before the proposal is accepted by a higher police official.

It further directed that, while directing the opening of a history sheet, the higher police authority shall record its reasons after considering the citizen's objection filed against the police station's report.

The Court passed the directions while allowing a criminal writ petition filed by Rais Ahmad, who had challenged the Class-A history sheet maintained against him at Police Station Chandausi in Moradabad district.

Case in brief

The petitioner approached the High Court seeking quashing of History Sheet and an order restraining the police from making domiciliary visits to his residence on the basis of the entry.

It was his case that he had been implicated in multiple criminal cases in 2005 under provisions of the IPC, the Arms Act and the Uttar Pradesh Gangsters Anti-Social Activities (Prevention) Act. He was subsequently acquitted in allthe  the cases.

Despite the acquittals, he contended that his name continued to figure in the Class-A history sheet and police personnel allegedly made frequent domiciliary visits to his residence.

The petitioner also submitted that he had not been implicated in any criminal case for nearly two decades and that the continued surveillance infringed his fundamental rights.

On the other hand, the State Government opposed the petition while contending that the history sheet had been opened in view of the petitioner's criminal antecedents.

It also claimed that he had been acquitted because no one dared to depose against him and that surveillance was therefore necessary.

The State further argued that the petitioner had an alternative remedy of making a representation to the Superintendent of Police.

High Court's observations

Examining the records of the case, the High Court noted that the petitioner had been acquitted in the criminal cases as well as the proceedings under the Gangsters Act.

The Bench observed that, when the history sheet was opened against him, no criminal case was pending against him.

It also referred to the communication issued by the Director General of Police, Uttar Pradesh, on November 3, 2022, which stated that history sheets should not be opened in a routine manner and should be opened only in cases involving habitual offenders who require intense surveillance.

The guidelines also clarified that implication under the U.P. Gangsters Act or the U.P. Goonda Act could not, by itself, constitute a ground for opening a history sheet.

The Court noted that the State had not produced any reasoned order demonstrating application of mind to the petitioner's case before opening the history sheet.

"We find that there is no reasoned order brought on record by State showing any application of mind to the case of the petitioner for opening history sheet," the Bench observed.

The High Court further examined the constitutional validity of the procedure governing the opening of history sheets under the U.P. Police Regulations.

It noted that the regulations were framed before Independence, at a time when the Constitution of India had not come into existence.

The Bench observed that, after the promulgation of the Constitution, compliance with the principles of natural justice under Article 14 had become imperative, particularly where an individual's right to life, livelihood and liberty was involved.

The Court added that opening a history sheet was not the same as implicating an individual in a criminal case. It further remarked thus:

"By opening history sheet the police gets the right of surveillance of the history sheeter. Whether the police report submitted before the higher police authority for approval is correct or not is not considered nor the person sought to be made a history sheeter is ever afforded opportunity to put his version against the police report. After opening of Class-B history sheet, the history sheeter remains under surveillance for life and his right to liberty is severely effected in the name of surveillance. He is vulnerable to police dictate, threat and coercion throughout his life".

"Such a person is condemned unheard", the Court observed, adding that subjecting a citizen of a sovereign democratic State to surveillance without such safeguards could not be said to be in accordance with Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution.

The Bench also pointed out that the DGP's guidelines dated November 3, 2022, provided for the opening and review of Class-A history sheets but did not contain corresponding safeguards for Class-B history sheets.

In view of the possibility of false implication on account of personal and political rivalry, the Court held that the provisions governing the opening of history sheets required reconsideration.

The Court accordingly directed the State Government to examine the procedure for opening history sheets and make or issue necessary amendments or guidelines to provide an opportunity to submit objections to a person against whom the police recommend the opening of a Class-A or Class-B history sheet.

The objection must be placed before the senior police official, who would decide whether to approve the proposal after considering the person's response. The authority must also record reasons for directing the opening of the history sheet.

In addition, the State Government has been directed to provide for an annual review of history sheets.

The Registrar (Compliance) has been directed to communicate the order to the Principal Secretary (Home), Uttar Pradesh, within one week.

Allowing the petition, the High Court quashed the history sheet opened against Ahmad and directed that surveillance against him be stopped forthwith.

Tags: