Click the Play button to listen to article
story

The Chhattisgarh High Court has held that an employee who accepts and joins a post offered on compassionate grounds cannot subsequently seek a change to a higher post on the basis of higher educational qualifications. The Court observed that once the petitioner has already been granted appointment on compassionate grounds to the post of Peon and has accepted and joined the said post, he...

Your free access to Live Law has expired
Please Subscribe for unlimited access to Live Law Archives, Weekly/Monthly Digest, Exclusive Notifications, Comments, Ad Free Version, Petition Copies, Judgement/Order Copies.

The Chhattisgarh High Court has held that an employee who accepts and joins a post offered on compassionate grounds cannot subsequently seek a change to a higher post on the basis of higher educational qualifications. The Court observed that once the petitioner has already been granted appointment on compassionate grounds to the post of Peon and has accepted and joined the said post, he cannot subsequently claim a change of post to a higher post of Assistant Grade-III on the same ground.

Justice Bibhu Datta Guru was hearing a writ petition filed by Mahendra Adil, who sought appointment as Assistant Grade-III in place of the Peon post offered to him following his father's death in harness.

The petitioner's father had served as a Revenue Inspector with the Municipal Corporation, Birgaon, and died on July 24, 2025. The petitioner was subsequently appointed as a Peon on May 5, 2026, pursuant to his application for compassionate appointment. After accepting and joining the post, he sought a change to Assistant Grade-III, citing his higher educational qualifications.

The petitioner contended that the applicable policy permitted compassionate appointments to Assistant Grade-III to the extent of 10% of the sanctioned strength. Since the Corporation had eight sanctioned posts, he argued that his request deserved consideration.

The State opposed the plea, relying on Clause 20(1) of the policy, which provides that once an applicant has been granted compassionate appointment, a subsequent request for appointment to another post or change of the post already offered cannot be entertained.

The Court noted that the petitioner had already accepted and joined the post of Peon. It held that Clause 20(1) expressly barred his subsequent request for a change of post. Hence, the Court observed that the petitioner's subsequent request for change of post from Peon to Assistant Grade-III cannot be entertained in view of the specific prohibition contained in the policy.

The Court further observed that a candidate has no right to claim appointment to a particular post of their choice on compassionate grounds. Such a candidate can only seek consideration for compassionate appointment, while the competent authority must decide the matter after considering relevant factors, including the availability of posts.

“… a candidate has no right to claim appointment to a particular post of his choice on compassionate grounds. He can only claim consideration of his candidature for compassionate appointment consequent upon the death of the breadwinner, and it is for the competent authority to decide the matter by taking into consideration various aspects, including the availability of posts in the establishment,” the Court remarked.

Finding no ground to direct the authorities to change the petitioner's post from Peon to Assistant Grade-III, the High Court dismissed the writ petition at the motion stage.

Case Title: Mahendra Adil v. State of Chhattisgarh & Ors. [WPS No. 7960 of 2026]

Full View
Tags: