Click the Play button to listen to article

The Chhattisgarh High Court has held that a mother's travel in connection with her government employment cannot, by itself, be a ground to conclude that she is incapable of looking after her child or to transfer custody to the father, particularly when he is also occupied with his professional commitments. The Court reiterated that the welfare and best interests of the child, rather than the preferential rights of either parent, must remain the paramount consideration in custody matters.

A Division Bench of Justice Parth Prateem Sahu and Justice Sushma Sawant was hearing an appeal filed challenging a Family Court order that rejected the applicant's plea seeking guardianship and custody of his minor son under Sections 7 and 10 of the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890.

The parties' marriage was dissolved in April 2023. Subsequently, under a Lok Adalat settlement dated May 13, 2023, the father agreed to pay monthly maintenance of ₹15,000 for the child and was granted visitation rights every Sunday.

The father contended that the mother had left the child in the care of his maternal grandparents, who were around 75 years old. He also alleged that the child's education was suffering and pointed to the child securing a 'C' grade in Class V. The mother opposed the application, submitting that the child was being cared for properly and that she had made arrangements for his upbringing during her official duties.

The Court reiterated the principle laid down by the Supreme Court in Nil Ratan Kundu v. Abhijit Kundu, that the paramount consideration in deciding custody and guardianship disputes is the welfare and well-being of the child, and not the preferential or legal rights of either parent.

Applying this principle, the Court observed that the mother's government employment and the requirement to travel for official duties could not, by themselves, establish her inability to care for the child. It noted that the father was also a doctor who practised in both Korba and Raipur.

“… the circumstance of professional engagements and consequent paucity of time is not confined to the respondent/defendant mother alone. Therefore, the aforesaid ground does not constitute a sufficient basis for appointing the appellant/plaintiff father as guardian and disturbing the existing arrangement,” the Court observed.

The Court further observed that the father had not produced cogent documentary evidence to establish that the child's academic performance had deteriorated or that the mother was neglecting his education.

“A mere reference to the grade obtained by the minor in a particular academic session, without any supporting material demonstrating neglect or adverse impact upon his education, cannot be treated as sufficient ground for changing his existing arrangement of care and upbringing,” the Court remarked.

The Court also interacted with the child, who was around 14 years old and expressed unwillingness to live with his father. While observing that the child's preference could not be the sole determining factor, the Court held that it deserved due consideration. It found no material to establish that the mother's care was adversely affecting the child's physical, educational or emotional welfare.

The Court accordingly dismissed the father's appeal and affirmed the Family Court's order refusing to transfer custody.

Case Title: Dr. Santosh Bhardwaj v. Smt. Bhorlaxmi Bhardwaj [FA(MAT) No. 346 of 2025]

Full View
Tags: