Karnataka High Court Quashes Hate Speech FIR Over Post Claiming Siddaramaiah Intended To Distribute Nation's Wealth To Muslims
The Karnataka High Court recently quashed a hate speech FIR registered against a social media user who had shared a news clip claiming that the then Karnataka Chief Minister Siddaramaiah had stated that the nation's wealth would be distributed to Muslims.
A single judge bench of Justice Rajesh Rai K allowed the petition filed by Vinith Narayan Naik, quashing the FIR registered under Section 153A of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) and Section 66C of the Information Technology Act, 2000.
The Court held that merely reposting a news item accompanied by comments expressing dissent, without promoting enmity between two distinct communities or demonstrating a likelihood of disturbing public tranquillity, would not attract Section 153A IPC.
"I am of the considered view that, even if the entire allegations made in the complaint and FIR are taken at their face value and accepted in their entirety, no offence is made out against the petitioner. Therefore, the continuation of FIR and further proceedings against the petitioner would amount to abuse of process of court," the Court observed.
The case arose from a complaint filed on April 29, 2024, by J. Saravanan, described as a Congress party worker and president from the Gandhinagar constituency. The complaint alleged that objectionable posts were being published on X (formerly Twitter) through an account named "BhikuMhatre (Modi's Family) @MumbaichaDon".
The posts included a photograph of a news item telecast by Kannada news channel TV9 carrying the headline, "I will share the wealth of the nation to Muslims: CM Siddaramaiah." The accompanying write-up criticised the Congress manifesto and referred to claims concerning its provisions for Muslims and Scheduled Castes/Scheduled Tribes.
According to the complainant, the posts were intended to promote hatred between Hindu and Muslim communities, disturb public peace and bring disrepute to the Congress Party.
Senior Advocate Aruna Shyam, appearing for Naik, argued that the complaint did not disclose the essential ingredients of Section 153A IPC. It was submitted that the petitioner had merely reposted a photograph of a news item concerning the then Chief Minister's remarks and had not made any statement intended to humiliate a particular community or incite hatred or violence against any group. The petitioner also alleged that the complaint had been filed with an ulterior political motive.
Opposing the plea, State Public Prosecutor B.N. Jagadeesha submitted that Siddaramaiah had stated that the nation's wealth would be distributed even to the Muslim community. However, TV9 had presented the statement in its breaking-news headline as suggesting that the wealth would be distributed to Muslims. The State argued that the petitioner had shared the news clipping with a write-up suggesting that the Congress Party intended to take away wealth belonging to Hindus and distribute it only to Muslims.
It contended that the post had the potential to provoke communal hatred and violence, thereby attracting Section 153A IPC. The prosecution also submitted that the investigation was at a nascent stage and that the FIR should not be quashed.
The High Court noted that the news item had admittedly been published by TV9 and that no investigation had been conducted to determine its genuineness. It therefore observed that the allegation against the petitioner was confined to reposting the photograph of the news item with the accompanying write-up.
Referring to the Supreme Court's judgment in Bilal Ahmed Kaloo v. State of Andhra Pradesh, the Court noted that Section 153A IPC requires the promotion of enmity, hatred or ill-will between two distinct religious or other groups.
"In the present case, admittedly, the petitioner, in the write-up accompanying the photograph of the then Chief Minister of Karnataka, has not specifically referred to or made any statement promoting enmity or hatred between two distinct communities or groups," the Court observed.
It further noted that the material on record did not disclose any tendency or likelihood of disturbing public tranquillity. It also referred to the constitutional protection afforded to lawful dissent under Article 19(1)(a) and the right to lead a dignified and meaningful life under Article 21, subject to reasonable restrictions under Article 19(2).
"In the instant case, the petitioner had merely reposted a news item disseminated by TV9 media, along with the photograph of the then Chief Minister of Karnataka, expressing his dissent through the accompanying write-up. In the absence of any specific reference to two distinct groups or communities, such an act, by itself, would not attract the ingredients of Section 153A of IPC," the Court held.
The Court further observed that the contents of the petitioner's post did not prima facie disclose an intention or tendency to vilify, humiliate or incite hatred or violence against a targeted community. It also took note of the fact that the complainant, a Congress party worker, had not appeared before the Court despite service of notice.
The Court ultimately held that even if the allegations in the complaint were accepted in their entirety, no offence was made out against Naik. Accordingly, it quashed the FIR.
Appearance: ARUNA SHYAM, SENIOR COUNSEL FOR SRI. SUYOG HERELE E, ADVOCATE for Petitioner.
SPP 1 B.N. JAGADEESH B.N, a/w SSP MAHESHA P, FOR R1