Karnataka High Court Declines Interim Relief To Distillery Against Restrictions On Ethanol Production Amid Sugar Scarcity
The Karnataka High Court has declined to grant interim relief to a distillery challenging the Central Government's restrictions on the production of ethanol from sugarcane juice and B-heavy molasses for the Ethanol Supply Year 2026–27, taking note of the prevailing shortage of sugar.
A single judge bench of Justice C M Poonacha refused to stay the Centre's orders dated October 22, 2026, which restricted sugar mills and distilleries from producing ethanol using sugarcane juice and B-heavy molasses.
The Court observed that the restrictions were imposed considering the prevailing sugar shortage and the estimated sugarcane production for 2026–27.
"The impugned orders dated 22.10.2026 have been passed having regard to the current situation whereunder there is a shortage of sugar, keeping in mind the estimates of the cane production for the year 2026-2027, the question of interdicting the impugned orders dated 22.10.2026 in any manner does not arise," the Court observed.
It further held that the commercial interests of the petitioners could not prevail over the restrictions imposed in view of the prevailing circumstances.
"The commercial activity of the petitioners cannot prevail over the impugned orders which have been issued due to the prevailing situation as noticed above," the Court said.
The Court was hearing a petition filed by M/s Askins Biofuels Private Limited, which claimed to be a standalone distillery engaged in the manufacture and production of ethanol, along with M/s Shri Bhramanandasagar Jaggery Industries.
The petitioners challenged the restrictions imposed by the Centre and sought permission to continue manufacturing ethanol.
Askins Biofuels submitted that it had entered into a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) with Shri Bhramanandasagar Jaggery Industries, a manufacturer of jaggery and jaggery products, for the supply of sugarcane juice and sugarcane syrup to be used in ethanol production.
The petitioners argued that their operations would not affect the 95% of sugarcane grown in the area reserved for supply to sugar factories. They claimed that the sugarcane required for their operations would be sourced from the remaining 5%, which farmers were free to sell at their discretion. It was further contended that allowing the restrictions to operate would bring their production activities to a standstill, adversely affect their functioning and cause irreparable financial losses.
The petitioners also relied on earlier judgments of the High Court in their favour concerning the applicability of the Sugarcane (Control) Order, 1966, to standalone distilleries.
Opposing the petition, Additional Solicitor General Arvind Kamath, appearing for the Union Government, submitted that the restrictions had been imposed under the powers conferred by Section 3 of the Essential Commodities Act, 1955, to address the shortage of sugar. It was argued that diverting sugarcane for ethanol production would affect the quantity of sugar available in the market.
The Centre further submitted that the restrictions were among several measures introduced after assessing the estimated sugar requirement and production for 2026–27.
The Court noted that the earlier judgments relied upon by the petitioners concerned orders issued under the Sugarcane (Control) Order, 1966, whereas the present restrictions had been imposed under the subsequent Sugar (Control) Order, 2025.
It also observed that the petitioners' claim of operating a standalone distillery was disputed, with material placed on record questioning the nature of their operations.
Considering the prevailing sugar shortage and the circumstances in which the restrictions were imposed, the Court held that no grounds were made out for interfering with the orders at the interim stage.
Accordingly, the Court rejected the prayer for interim relief, while granting liberty to the petitioners to approach the concerned authorities seeking permission or relaxation as permissible under law.
Appearance:
Advocate Nayak Anirudha Ramchandra for Petitioner.
ASG Arvind Kamath a/w CGC Chandan Sanjay Bhat for R1.