Madras High Court Refuses To Interfere With NGT's Construction Ban Near Pallikaranai Ramsar Site, Cites Supreme Court Proceedings
The Madras High Court has refused to interfere with an order of the National Green Tribunal, Southern Zone, through which the Chennai Metropolitan Development Authority (CMDA) was asked not to grant planning permission inside the Pallikaranai Ramsar site and its 1km zone of influence until an Integrated Management Plan (IMP) was finalised. [2026 LiveLaw (Mad) 553] The bench of...
The Madras High Court has refused to interfere with an order of the National Green Tribunal, Southern Zone, through which the Chennai Metropolitan Development Authority (CMDA) was asked not to grant planning permission inside the Pallikaranai Ramsar site and its 1km zone of influence until an Integrated Management Plan (IMP) was finalised. [2026 LiveLaw (Mad) 553]
The bench of Chief Justice SA Dharmadhikari and Justice G Arul Murugan noted that the Supreme Court was already monitoring ground-truthing and boundary demarcation of the Ramsar site. The bench held that when the highest court was actively monitoring the same, judicial discipline warranted that the High Court refrain from passing any orders.
“Judicial discipline demands that when the highest court of the land is actively monitoring the ground-truthing and boundary demarcation of the very same wetland, a High Court must refrain from passing parallel or conflicting orders altering its protective perimeter. Even the revised proposal submitted by the TNSWA on 01.10.2026 expressly states that it is merely a tentative arrangement and that the final Zone of Influence can only be notified after the ground-truthing exercise is completed….Adjudicating these boundary disputes or carving out exceptions while the Supreme Court is seized of the wetland demarcation exercise would, in our firm view, be improper,” the court said.
The court was hearing a batch of petitions filed by real estate associations, builders, resident welfare associations, trusts, and private patta landowners challenging the planning freeze. Some petitions also challenged the order issued by CMDA by which a total freeze was imposed on planning approvals. A challenge was also made to the proceedings issued by the National Centre for Sustainable Coastal Management (NCSCM) on the ground that the interim map prepared by the agency wrongly included their private patta land in Sholinganallur Village within the marshland boundary.
The petitioners argued that the NGT had initiated a suo motu inquiry into an alleged road encroachment in the site and had exceeded its statutory power by imposing a sweeping town-planning freeze. The petitioners argued that the Tribunal could not step into the shoes of a statutory planning authority or override Master Plans framed under the Tamil Nadu Town and Country Planning Act, 1971.
The petitioners also argued that the Zone of Influence had to be determined scientifically based on local hydrology, slope, drainage inlets, and land use, followed by ground truthing, a draft notification, and a 60-day public consultation. He added that imposing a mechanical ban without following the mandatory steps violated the Rules and Ramsar Convention guidelines.
The petitioners also argued that freezing vested development rights on patta lands classified as residential zones without statutory backing violates Article 14 and 300A of the Constitution.
The State informed the court that the Wetlands (Conservation and Management) Rules, 2017 do not prescribe an automatic 1-km buffer. It was submitted that a comprehensive state-wide exercise, involving digital mapping and physical ground truthing, was currently underway to fix the exact boundary of the Pallikaranai Ramsar Site.
The State also informed that pursuant to the bench's interim directions, the government had convened a high-level meeting with the NCSCM and technical experts, and the NCSCM had submitted a scientific assessment proposing a variable-width Interim Zone of Influence. It was also submitted that the authority had proposed allowing regulated construction in this zone subject to environmental safeguards and a No Objection Certificate from the District Level Wetlands Management Committee, rather than enforcing an absolute ban.
Though the State challenged the maintainability of the plea, arguing that an order of the NGT should be challenged before the Supreme Court, the court rejected this contention. The court noted that the petitioners were not parties to the proceedings before the NGT, yet an order affecting the rights of thousands of landowners across 15 villages was passed without notice to them. The court added that an alternative statutory remedy does not bar a writ petition where an authority had acted without jurisdiction or violated the principles of natural justice.
However, noting the pendency of proceedings, the court was not inclined to interfere with the order. The court directed the parties to move appropriate application in the proceedings pending before the Supreme Court or to initiate fresh proceedings seeking clarification or modification of Zone of Influence.
The court also directed the Tamil Nadu State Wetland Authority, the Directorate of Survey and Settlement, and the National Centre for Sustainable Coastal Management to complete the ground-truthing, boundary demarcation, and statutory notification process in strict compliance with the Wetlands (Conservation and Management) Rules, 2017, and the directions of the Supreme Court.
Counsel for Petitioner: Mr. P. S. Raman Senior Counsel for Mr. R. Saravana Kumar, Mr. Muthucharan Sundresh, Mr. S. Gokul, Ms. G. Sumitra, Ms. Sumathi Lokesh, Mr. G. Adithyaraj, Mr. G. Dhinesh, Ms. Aparna Raju for M/s. G. Vijay Anand Associates
Counsel for Respondents: Mr. P. V. Balasubramaniam Addl. Advocate General assisted by Mr. Mohammed Fayaz Ali Spl. Government Pleader, Mr. T. Gowthaman Addl. Advocate General assisted by Mr. R. S. Raveendran Standing Counsel for CMDA, Mr. C. A. Ramanan Government Advocate, Mr. L. Gokulraj Addl. Government Pleader