Madras High Court Refuses To Quash Extortion Case Against Savukku Shankar, Says Malicious Prosecution Claim Can Be Considered Only After Trial
The Madras High Court has refused to quash a criminal case registered against YouTuber Savukku Shankar alleging that he had extorted money from a film producer.
Though Shankar had claimed that the case was registered with malicious intent, Justice GK Ilanthiraiyan held that the same could not be gone into at the stage of the quashing plea and could be decided only after concluding the trial.
“Further, this Court cannot observe at this stage as to whether the initiation of criminal proceeding itself is malicious or not. The same is required to be considered at the conclusion of the trial. Therefore, the ground raised by the petitioner to quash the final report/charge sheet cannot be entertained,” the court said.
The case against Shankar was registered under Sections 296(b), 351(2), 308(3), 131, 115(2), 109, 353 (1)(b), and 61 (2)(b) of the BNS.
According to the prosecution, Shankar made defamatory statements regarding an upcoming movie, “Red and Follow”, alleging that the movie was being produced using money derived from the sale of narcotic drugs. When the de facto complainant, the producer of the movie, demanded that Shankar remove the defamatory and damaging content, Shankar allegedly demanded a sum of Rs 10,00,000.
Later, when the producer went to Shankar's office to meet him, Shankar and his men are alleged to have used filthy language, assaulted him and threatened to do away with his life, while kicking him in his private parts. It was also alleged that Shankar and his men snatched a sum of Rs 1,00,000 from his possession. Thus, he lodged a complaint.
It may be noted that in December last year, Shankar was granted interim bail for a period of 3 months by a vacation bench of the High Court. Since the interim bail was primarily granted due to health concerns, the court had later directed setting up of a medical board to assess Shankar's health condition. Taking note of the board's report, the court had closed pleas against his solitary confinement and sought specialised medical treatment.
In May this year, Shankar was granted bail by the High Court in the case.
Seeking to quash the case, Shankar argued that no such occurrence had taken place and there were material contradictions in the statements of witnesses. Shankar also alleged that the final report did not constitute the essential ingredients of the offences alleged against him. He also argued that the criminal proceedings were initiated with mala fide intentions to harass him and suppress his journalistic activities.
After looking into the final report, the court noted that there were specific allegations against Shankar, which were sufficient to attract the offences as alleged. The court also noted that the veracity of the allegations could be determined only at the stage of trial, upon appreciation of evidence. The court added that the grounds raised by Shankar involved disputed questions of fact, which could not be adjudicated at this stage.
Thus, the court was not inclined to quash the case registered against Shankar. The court added that Shankar would be at liberty to raise all grounds before the trial court and also asked the trial court to complete the trial within 6 months.
Counsel for Petitioner: Mr. P. Rajkumar Pandian
Counsel for Respondent: Mr. R. Ganesh Kumar Additional Public Prosecutor