Click the Play button to listen to article

The Supreme Court has held that an arbitrator or umpire cannot award compensation beyond the monetary limit of the dispute expressly referred to arbitration by a party.

Adjudicating a matter under the Arbitration Act, 1940, a bench of Justice Dipankar Datta and Justice Satish Chandra Sharma held that an umpire cannot enlarge the scope of the reference by relying on subsequent correspondence or a party's reservation of rights to claim additional damages.

The dispute arose from a 1986 technical collaboration agreement between Neycer (India) Ltd. and GMB Ceramics Ltd. under which Neycer was to provide technical assistance for setting up a sanitaryware manufacturing plant. Alleging delays and breaches of contractual obligations, GMB claimed damages, including losses arising from project cost overruns, projected advertising expenditure and interest on loans.

When GMB initiated arbitration proceedings in 1989, it quantified its claim at ₹2 crores in correspondence nominating its arbitrator. However, the Umpire subsequently awarded GMB approximately ₹11.69 crore.

Neycer challenged the award. In 2015, a Single Judge of the Calcutta High Court restricted the award to ₹2 crores, holding that the Umpire could not travel beyond the scope of the reference. The Division Bench reversed this decision in 2018, prompting Neycer to approach the Supreme Court.

Allowing the appeal, the judgment authored by Justice Datta held that GMB's correspondence had crystallised the monetary limit of the reference at ₹2 crores; hence, the claims could not enlarge the disputes actually referred to arbitration.

“Umpire, it is settled law, cannot confer jurisdiction upon himself by misconstruing the terms of the reference.”, the Court observed.

The Court also upheld the rejection of GMB's claim for projected advertising expenditure, noting that actual expenditure was available in the company's audited accounts and the higher estimate had not been proved through the person who prepared it.

It further held that Neycer's contractual obligation to “endeavour to commission” the plant did not make it a “turnkey guarantee or an insurance policy underwriting GMB's entire business profitability and debt servicing for five years”.

The Court, however, declined to interfere with the other claims sustained by the Single Judge within the ₹2-crore limit.

Considering that Neycer had deposited ₹4 crores, comprising ₹2 crore towards the principal award and ₹2 crore towards interest, which GMB had already withdrawn, the Court directed that this amount would constitute full and final satisfaction of the modified award. Neither party would be entitled to recover any further amount.

As a result, the appeals were accordingly allowed, and the Single Judge's order was restored.

Tags: