The Supreme Court on Thursday (November 19) held that a suit under Section 92 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC) is representative in nature, but this does not give every devotee or member of the institution an automatic right to be impleaded.
A bench of Justice Vikram Nath, Justice Sandeep Mehta, and Justice Aparesh Kumar Singh observed so while setting aside the Calcutta High Court's orders, which included an interim order staying the trial court's removal of a Special Officer, and orders setting aside the rejection of impleadment applications.
The matter pertains to the administration of Sri Guru Sangha, a charitable society registered under the Societies Registration Act, 1860, with its central Ashram at Kolkata. The appellants (members of the Sangha) filed a suit under Section 92 CPC, seeking removal of certain office bearers, framing of a scheme for management, and appointment of a receiver. For context, Section 92 deals with representative suits relating to public charitable or religious trusts.
During the suit, the trial court appointed a Special Officer to oversee the Sangha's administration. On the plaintiffs' complaints alleging irregularities, it later removed the Officer and constituted a 13-member ad hoc committee, with directions for quarterly reports and annual audits. The trial court's order was stayed by an interim order passed by the High Court. The Supreme Court stayed that interim order and later confirmed the protection.
In a separate development, the trial court rejected impleadment applications filed by the respondents. The High Court set aside the rejection order and allowed the applicants to file fresh applications. The Supreme Court stayed those orders in March this year.
Removal Of Special Officer:
The Supreme Court held that the trial court was competent to make interim arrangements for the administration and protection of the Sangha, observing that the appointment of a Special Officer did not confer any vested right to continue in the position.
It noted that the trial court had called for the Special Officer's explanation, which was submitted and considered. The ad hoc committee was constituted on a joint application of the parties, with safeguards of periodic reporting and audit. It observed that there was no sufficient justification for the High Court to stay the arrangement made by the trial court.
With regards to the High Court's supervisory jurisdiction, the bench relied on M/s Garment Craft v Prakash Chand Goel, to reiterate that Article 227 jurisdiction is not intended to correct every error of fact or law and does not permit the High Court to substitute its own conclusions for those of the subordinate court, and that interference is warranted only where there is a patent jurisdictional error, perversity or grave miscarriage of justice.
The bench found that the High Court proceeded on the premise that the Special Officer was removed without a hearing, whereas the trial court's order recorded that her written explanation was called for, submitted and considered. The bench observed that the High Court did not examine why the opportunity so afforded was insufficient or identify any other infirmity, and held that such interim interference was unwarranted.
Impleadment Under O1 R10(2) CPC:
The bench observed that Order I Rule 10(2) requires the court to determine whether the presence of a proposed party is necessary or proper for effective and complete adjudication of the suit. It held as under:
“Although a suit instituted under Section 92 of the CPC is representative in nature and concerns the interests of persons associated with the institution, this does not confer an automatic right of impleadment upon every devotee or member of the Sangha. The applicants must demonstrate sufficient grounds for their separate participation and explain how their presence is necessary or proper for the adjudication of the controversy. In the present case, the Trial Court, by its reasoned order dated 09.09.2025, found that the applicants had failed to establish such grounds. Their general allegations of collusion and mismanagement, without sufficient particulars demonstrating the necessity of their presence, were found inadequate to justify impleadment.”
The bench observed that the High Court set aside the order mainly because the suit was representative and the interests of others might be affected. “While that consideration is relevant, it cannot, by itself, dispense with the requirements of Order I Rule 10(2) of the CPC,” it observed, adding that the High Court identified no perversity in the trial court's findings and gave liberty to file fresh applications without addressing the trial court's reasons.
“Such interference, in the absence of any demonstrated legal infirmity in the exercise of discretion by the Trial Court, was not justified,” the bench held.
Plea For Fresh Administrator Rejected:
The respondents had also filed interlocutory applications before the Supreme Court, alleging about the ad hoc committee's functioning and anticipated donations during forthcoming religious celebrations, and sought an independent administrator or a fresh committee. However, the bench declined to do so, holding that the allegations involved disputed questions which cannot appropriately be determined in the present proceedings. It further observed that the trial court is competent to examine irregularities brought to its notice and issue appropriate directions.
“We have also considered the subsequent developments brought on record, particularly the allegations concerning the functioning and financial management of the ad hoc committee. However, these allegations involve disputed questions which cannot appropriately be determined in the present proceedings. The Trial Court continues to exercise jurisdiction over the underlying suit and is competent to examine any irregularities brought to its notice and issue appropriate directions for the protection and administration of the Sangha. We are, therefore, not inclined to direct the appointment of a fresh committee or administrator at this stage. Any grievance concerning the existing arrangements may be raised before the Trial Court, which shall consider the same independently and in accordance with law.”
In the light of aforesaid, the High Court's interim order was set aside and the trial court's order was restored.
“Accordingly, Civil Appeal Nos. 841 and 842 of 2023 are allowed. The common interim order dated 26.09.2022 passed by the High Court in C.O. Nos. 2726 and 2334 of 2022 is set aside. Consequently, the order dated 07.06.2022 passed by the Trial Court shall remain operative, subject to any further orders passed by the competent court in accordance with law.”
The bench further clarified that its observation shall have no bearing on the merits of the case.
Appearances:
For Appellants: Mr. Shoeb Alam, Sr. Adv.; Ms. Rashmi Nandakumar, Adv.; Mr. Sujoy Chatterjee, AOR; Ms. Saloni Narayan, Adv.; Ms. Hikmah Wani, Adv.; Ms. Yashmita Pandey, Adv.; Mr. Khalid Ali, Adv.
For Respondents: Mr. Sagar Suri, AOR; Mr. Sudhanshu S Chaudhary, Sr. Adv.; Mr. Sudhanshu S Choudhary, Sr. Adv.; Mr. Kunal Malik, AOR; Ms. Shraddha Chirania, Adv.; Mr. Vikalp Gupta, Adv.; Ms. Niti Priya Kar, Adv.; Mr. Jatin Kumar, Adv.; Ms. Priyanka, Adv.; Mr. Pulkit Agarwal, AOR