The Supreme Court held that a person who did not participate in an auction and is a stranger to it acquires no locus or right to seek confirmation of the bid in his favour merely by offering a higher price at a later stage.
A bench of Justice BV Nagarathna and Justice R Mahadevan ruled so while setting aside an order of the Madhya Pradesh High Court (Indore) Division Bench which had remanded an application filed by such a non-participant to the Company Judge.
“Merely because a person who has not participated in an auction proceedings and is a stranger thereto seeks to enter the fray by making a higher bid at a later stage would not confer any locus or right on such a party to seek conferment of the bid in his favour,” the bench ruled.
The appeal arose from the liquidation of the respondent company. In an e-auction held in 2025, the appellant emerged as the highest bidder at Rs 31 crores, against a reserve price of Rs 29 crores. A third party later offered Rs 35 crores. The High Court rejected that offer and asked whether the appellant would revise its bid to that amount, to which the appellant agreed.
Later, Respondent 2 (R2) who had also not participated in the auction filed an interlocutory application seeking to participate, offering Rs 42.25 crores. The Company Judge rejected the application and accepted the appellant's enhanced bid of Rs 35 crores. In appeal, the Division Bench remanded the application for fresh consideration and directed the Official Liquidator not to execute the sale deed in the meantime, relying on precedents that held that higher offers by third parties could be considered even after a sale certificate had been issued.
A review petition was also filed but was dismissed subsequent to which the matter reached before the Supreme Court.
The Supreme Court held that the Division Bench was not right in remanding the matter, noting that R2 had neither participated in the auction nor made any bid on the date of the auction.
“Therefore, respondent No.2 is a stranger and not a person aggrieved by the auction which took place on the said date in which the appellant was declared to be the highest bidder. That being the position of respondent No.2, he could not have intervened in the liquidation proceedings by filing an application namely, I.A. No.170/2026. It was highly speculative and without any locus standi on the part of the said respondent to have filed the said application at all.”
It further added that the Company Judge had rightly declined to entertain the application, and that the Division Bench failed to notice that R2 had no locus standi.
The bench relied on Jasbhai Motibhai Desai v Roshan Kumar, Haji Bashir Ahmed and explained that an applicant ordinarily falls into one of three categories - as an aggrieved person, as a stranger, or as a busybody or meddlesome interloper, and the tests for distinguishing a person aggrieved from a stranger is whether the applicant's legal right has been infringed and whether he has a special and substantial grievance beyond that suffered by the rest of the public.
Reliance was also placed on Golden Food Products India v State of UP and Ors, wherein the Court referred to K Kumara Gupta v Sri Markendaya & Sri Omkareswara Swamy Temple to hold that unless there is material irregularity, illegality, fraud or collusion, it is not open to set aside an auction or sale in favour of the highest bidder on the basis of some representation made by a third party who did not even participate even in the auction proceedings and did not make any offer. It also observed that repeated interference would frustrate the object and sanctity of public auctions.
Further reliance was placed on Eva Agro Feeds (P) Ltd. v Punjab National Bank observing that the mere expectation of a still higher price can be no good ground to cancel an otherwise valid auction, as this would lead to avoidable expenses and erode the credibility of the auction process. It also recalled that “merely because the authority conducting the auction expected a higher bid than what the highest bidder had bid cannot be a reason to discard the highest bid.”
In the light of aforesaid, the Division Bench's order was set aside while also noting that the appellant had already deposited Rs. 35 crores. Thus, it directed the Official Liquidator to hand over possession of the land to the appellant once the legal formalities are fulfilled.
“In the circumstances, we set aside the impugned order of the Division Bench of the High Court. We also dismiss I.A. No.170/2026 filed by respondent No.2 herein. The appeals are allowed in the aforesaid terms.”
“At this stage, learned senior counsel categorically submitted that the appellant has already deposited a sum of Rs.35 crores and the said fact is also acknowledged by learned counsel for the Official Liquidator.”
“The official liquidator shall handover possession of the subject land to the appellant herein immediately after all legal formalities are completed including registration of the sale deed.”
Case:
Appearances:
For Appellant: Mr. Shashank Garg, Sr. Adv.; Mr. Shivam Sachdeva, Adv.; Mr. Himansh Yadav, Adv.; Mr. Devvrat, AOR; Mr. Abhinav Malhotra, Adv.; Ms. Divyansha, Adv.; Mr. Vinod Kumar Jaiswal, Adv.
For Respondents: Ms Mrinmayee Sahu, AOR; Mr. Jitin Chaturvedi, Adv.; Ms. Amruta Padhi, Adv.; Mr. S Niranjan Reddy, Sr. Adv.; Mr. Ankit Chaturvedi, AOR; Mr. Shubham Agarwal, Adv.; Ms. Gaargi Singh, Adv.; Ms. Tarjana Rai, Adv.; Ms. Tripti Jain, Adv.; Mr. Prakhar Karpe, Adv.; Mr. Vineet Shrivastawa, Adv.; Mr. Shekhar Sharma, Sr. Adv.; Mr. Shubhankar Sharma, Adv.; Ms. Sneha Sanjay Botwe, AOR