Gujarat Riots- Zakia Jafri's Plea Against Clean Chit To Narendra Modi- LIVE UPDATES From Supreme Court Hearing

Sibal: At pg 78 The HC says Mag. should have further investigated. But HC itself does not direct. Then at Pg 83 larger conspiracy and findings. Kindly come to 13.7 at Pg 86.

Sibal: Pg 72 now, para 10.3...So he says all that was done (S.173 investigation) prior to 12th Nov (final order of SC).

Sibal: Now, let's go to the HC order. Upto page 70 is the background. Kindly look at the bottom, you’ll find judicial evaluation.

Sibal: Now you know what he has taken into consideration. I say with humility, none of the material. And the material based on disputed question of fact, I have not argued.

Sibal: Without referring to any material of hate speeches, all the material I had pointed out in Vol IV see what he (Mag) says - S 153A is not satisfied. He rejected both S. 153A and 153B. This was w.r.t the ex CM. All of the hate material not considered. 

Sibal: You (police) don’t answer fire brigade, you don’t do preventive action, all that is irrelevant for him (Mag). This is all he (Mag) does w.r.t. the officers concerned.

Sibal: So the fact is that SIT did not ask for material. These reports were with SIT, part of document with SIT. He (Mag) does not deal with hate speech.We have one volume for hate speech. He does not look at that. He then deals with role of police officers.

Sibal: Then he deals with NHRC.

Sibal:He says that in protest petition additional evidence is brought about,he says I’ll not look at that only.What evidence, it was official record. He only looks at the complaint.That is not what the SC had said. [Mag says]Court had only power to see Gulberg conspiracy case.

Sibal: On conspiracy he (Mag) says. HC says Mag. dealt with everything.