Designation Not Enough To Attract NI Act Liability: Calcutta High Court Quashes Cheque Bounce Case Against Independent Directors
The Calcutta High Court has quashed cheque dishonour proceedings under Sections 138 and 141 of the Negotiable Instruments Act against a company secretary and two non-executive independent directors of Tantia Constructions Limited, observing that merely holding a designation in a company does not make an individual criminally liable for its affairs.
Justice Ajay Kumar Gupta held that the complainant had failed to attribute any specific role to the three individuals in the transaction or issuance of the dishonoured cheque, or demonstrate that they were in charge of and responsible for the day-to-day business of the company at the relevant time.
The Court observed that non-executive and independent directors cannot be prosecuted under Section 138 read with Section 141 of the NI Act in the absence of specific allegations demonstrating their direct involvement in the affairs of the company.
“A Director of a company who was not in charge or responsible for the conduct of the business of the company at the relevant time, will not be liable for offence punishable under Section 138/141 of the N.I.Act. The liability under Section 138/141 of the N.I.Act arises from being in charge of and responsible for the conduct of the business of the company at the relevant time when the offence was committed, and not on the basis of merely holding a designation or office in a company,” the Court observed.
The Court was hearing two criminal revisional applications filed by directors and other officers of Tantia Constructions Limited, seeking quashing of cheque dishonour proceedings initiated by M/s Wide Range Sales Pvt. Ltd.
The complainant company had alleged that the accused persons had approached it for an inter-corporate deposit to promote their business. Accordingly, Wide Range Sales had advanced Rs 1 crore to Tantia Constructions on June 14, 2012. The deposit was renewed from time to time, with the latest renewal being for 91 days from April 1, 2014, carrying interest at 17 per cent per annum.
For repayment, Tantia Constructions issued an account-payee cheque dated July 1, 2014, for Rs 1 crore. However, when presented for encashment, the cheque was dishonoured on September 11, 2014, with the remark "Exceeds Arrangement".
Following the dishonour and failure to pay despite a demand notice, the complainant initiated proceedings under Sections 138 and 141 of the NI Act against the company and 11 individuals associated with it. The Metropolitan Magistrate, 14th Court, Calcutta, issued summons against the accused persons on July 20, 2015.
The petitioners contended that the complaint did not disclose their individual roles in the transaction or explain how they were responsible for the company's day-to-day affairs. They argued that merely describing them as directors or office-bearers was insufficient to attract vicarious criminal liability under Section 141 of the NI Act.
In particular, Tarun Chaturvedi and Madhuchhanda Chatterjee contended that they were non-executive independent directors, while Md. Jamshed Alam was the company's secretary. They submitted that none of them had participated in the transaction or issuance of the cheque.
The complainant opposed the petitions, arguing that the accused persons were involved in the company's day-to-day affairs and were responsible for its debts and liabilities. It contended that the proceedings should continue to establish their actual roles and liabilities.
The Court noted that the complainant had not specified the individual roles played by the accused persons during the transaction or issuance of the cheque. It also pointed out that the complaint did not identify the signatory of the dishonoured cheque.
Upon examining the documents, the Court found that Tarun Chaturvedi and Madhuchhanda Chatterjee were non-executive independent directors, while Md. Jamshed Alam was the company secretary. There was no material to indicate that they were active directors involved in the company's day-to-day management or financial transactions.
The Court observed that the liability of a non-executive company secretary was limited and did not extend to managing the company's day-to-day affairs. It further noted that the three petitioners were not signatories to the dishonoured cheque.
Referring to Section 149(12) of the Companies Act, 2013, the Court observed that an independent director or a non-executive director who is not a promoter or key managerial personnel can be held liable only in respect of acts or omissions committed with their knowledge, attributable through Board processes, and with their consent or connivance, or where they had failed to act diligently.
It held that an independent director could be held responsible under Section 141(2) of the NI Act only when a specific, direct and distinct role was attributed to them in the commission of the offence. A bald allegation without details of their involvement would not suffice.
Accordingly, the Court held that continuing the proceedings against Md. Jamshed Alam, Tarun Chaturvedi and Madhuchhanda Chatterjee would amount to an abuse of the process of law.
However, the Court declined to quash the proceedings against the remaining petitioners, who were described as full-time directors, additional directors and directors.
It noted that they had failed to produce authenticated or certified documents establishing that they were independent or non-executive directors. The Court held that in the absence of such material, the proceedings could not be quashed merely because the complaint did not provide further particulars of their individual roles, as the basic averment regarding their responsibility for the company's business was sufficient to send them to trial.
The Court thus partly allowed CRR 2828 of 2017 and allowed CRR 142 of 2016, quashing the proceedings against the company secretary and the two independent directors while allowing the case against the remaining accused persons to continue in accordance with law.
Case Title: Shaleen Khemani & Ors. v. State of West Bengal & Anr. (CRR 2828 of 2017) along with Tarun Chaturvedi & Anr. v. M/s Wide Range Sales Pvt. Ltd. (CRR 142 of 2016)