Click the Play button to listen to article
story

The Gauhati High Court has modified the conviction of a man sentenced to 25 years imprisonment for sexually assaulting a minor girl after finding that the victim was above 12 years of age at the time of the incident.The High Court held that the aggravated offence applicable to sexual assault on a child below 12 years under Section 6 POCSO Act was not attracted and thus altered his conviction...

Your free access to Live Law has expired
Please Subscribe for unlimited access to Live Law Archives, Weekly/Monthly Digest, Exclusive Notifications, Comments, Ad Free Version, Petition Copies, Judgement/Order Copies.

The Gauhati High Court has modified the conviction of a man sentenced to 25 years imprisonment for sexually assaulting a minor girl after finding that the victim was above 12 years of age at the time of the incident.

The High Court held that the aggravated offence applicable to sexual assault on a child below 12 years under Section 6 POCSO Act was not attracted and thus altered his conviction to Section 4(2) penetrative sexual assault and sentenced him to 20 years of rigorous imprisonment.

A Division Bench of Justice Michael Zothankhuma and Justice Sanjeev Kumar Sharma was hearing an appeal against the conviction under Section 448 (House Trespass) of IPC and Section 6 (Aggravated Penetrative Sexual Assault) of POCSO Act.

 While examining the victim's age, the Court found that the prosecution had not established that she was below 12 years on the date of the incident.

The seizure list through which the victim's birth certificate was seized recorded her date of birth as May 5, 2009. Although the seizure list was exhibited before the trial court, the birth certificate itself was not exhibited. Going by the date of birth recorded in the seizure list, the victim was above 12 years of age when the incident took place.

The Court noted that Section 5(m) states that committing penetrative sexual assault on a child below 12 years of age amounts to aggravated penetrative sexual assault. It therefore held that the provision was not attracted and thus punishment of 25 year jail provided under Section 6 for aggravated penetrative sexual assault could not be sustained.

The Court also considered the victim's radiological examination which indicated that she was below 12 years of age. Relying on the Supreme Court decision in Jaya Mala v. Home Secretary, Government of Jammu and Kashmir (1982) 2 SCC 538, the Court noted that radiological age assessment carries a possible margin of error of two years on either side. It observed that even if two years were added to the age indicated by the radiological examination, the victim would still be below 14 years and in any event below 16 years.

The Court accordingly held that the accused was liable to be convicted under Section 4(2) of the POCSO Act which prescribes a minimum sentence of 20 years for penetrative sexual assault on a child below 16 years of age.

Modifying the conviction, the Court held:

“In view of the reasons stated above, the conviction and sentence of the appellant under Section 6 of the POCSO Act is hereby set aside as Section 5(m) of the POCSO Act is not attracted. However, the victim being below 16 years of age at the time of being subjected to penetrative sexual assault by the appellant, the appellant is guilty of having committed the offence of penetrative sexual assault under Section 4(2) POCSO Act.”

The case arose from an incident on August 1, 2021 when the accused allegedly entered the victim house while she was alone and sexually assaulted her. Her father returned home during the incident and witnessed the assault. When he tried to intervene, the accused pushed him and fled.

The trial court had convicted the accused under Section 448 IPC and Section 6 of the POCSO Act. It sentenced him to one year of rigorous imprisonment for house trespass and 25 years for aggravated penetrative sexual assault.

The High Court upheld the finding that the accused had committed penetrative sexual assault. It noted that the victim's testimony was corroborated by her father's account who had witnessed the incident as well as the medical evidence. The doctor had found that the victim's hymen was ruptured and that she was approximately four weeks pregnant.

Rejecting the defence argument that the victim's failure to raise an alarm cast doubt on the allegation, the Court observed:

“With regard to the stand taken by the appellant's counsel that the victim did not cry out at the time of the rape, we have to remind ourselves of the fact that the victim is a young child and just because a victim of sexual assault does not cry out at the time of the sexual assault, does not mean that no rape had occurred. A victim of a sexual assault need not cry out for fear at the time of the sexual assault and it cannot be said that the victim had not been raped, only because she did not cry out.”

The Court also rejected the argument that the absence of injuries on the victim's private parts undermined the prosecution case. It observed:

“On considering the above facts, we have no doubt that the Prosecution has been able to prove that the appellant had committed penetrative sexual assault on the victim. Further, it is not necessary that there has to be an injury on the private parts of the victim, to prove that rape had been committed.”

The Court consequently set aside the conviction under Section 6 and convicted the accused under Section 4(2) of the POCSO Act. It sentenced him to 20 years of rigorous imprisonment with a fine of Rs 20,000. In default of payment, he will undergo an additional two years of rigorous imprisonment.

The Court did not interfere with the conviction and one-year sentence under Section 448 IPC. Both sentences will run concurrently.

Counsel for Appellant: Mr. S. Biswas, Legal Aid Counsel

Counsel for Respondent: Mr. R.R. Kaushik, Additional Public Prosecutor

Tags: