Click the Play button to listen to article
story

The Gauhati High Court has upheld the life imprisonment awarded to a man for murdering his brother by observing that defects in an investigation cannot automatically entitle an accused to acquittal when the prosecution evidence establishes guilt beyond reasonable doubt.A Division Bench of Justice Michael Zothankhuma and Justice Sanjeev Kumar Sharma dismissed the appeal challenging the...

Your free access to Live Law has expired
Please Subscribe for unlimited access to Live Law Archives, Weekly/Monthly Digest, Exclusive Notifications, Comments, Ad Free Version, Petition Copies, Judgement/Order Copies.

The Gauhati High Court has upheld the life imprisonment awarded to a man for murdering his brother by observing that defects in an investigation cannot automatically entitle an accused to acquittal when the prosecution evidence establishes guilt beyond reasonable doubt.

A Division Bench of Justice Michael Zothankhuma and Justice Sanjeev Kumar Sharma dismissed the appeal challenging the conviction under Sections 448 (House Trespass) and Section 302 (Murder) of the Indian Penal Code (IPC).

The appellant had argued that the investigation was defective because the seized clothes of the deceased were not marked by the police and the weapon allegedly used in the crime was not produced before the trial court. He contended that these lapses warranted his acquittal.

Rejecting the argument, the Court observed:

"In any event, in the case Mritunjoy Biswas Vs. Pranab @ Kuti Biswas and Anr., reported in (2013) 12 SCC 796, the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that non-recovery of weapon is not fatal to the Prosecution case, if there is direct evidence to the crime. In the present case, the weapon (dao) has been seized by the police and identified by PW-3 in Court. Even if the same had not been seized or produced at the time of examining the Prosecution witnesses, the same would not lead to the acquittal of the accused, inasmuch as, there is an eyewitness to the crime in question.
With regard to the submission made by the appellant's counsel that the seized clothes of the deceased not being marked by the police amounted to a defect in the investigation, we have to remind ourselves of the fact that the Supreme Court has repeatedly affirmed that a defective or faulty investigation does not automatically result in the acquittal of an accused, nor does it vitiate  the trial or the Prosecution case, unless the defect is fatal, i.e, unless the defect goes to the core of the case, causing unmitigated prejudice to an accused".

The Court relied on the Supreme Court decisions in Arvind Kumar @ Nemichand versus State of Rajasthan, 2021 SCC OnLine SC, 1099 and C. Muniappan versus State of Tamil Nadu, (2010) 9 SCC 567, reiterating that courts must examine the reliability of the prosecution evidence and whether any investigative lapse affected the process of finding the truth.

The court said that while dealing with a defective investigation, a Court of law is expected to sift the evidence available and find out the truth, on the principle that every case involves a journey towards truth.

The case arose from an incident on February 10, 2018 when the appellant allegedly quarrelled with his brother, returned with a dao and dragged him into the courtyard before repeatedly assaulting him. The deceased's wife witnessed the incident and lodged an FIR the following morning.

The High Court relied on her eyewitness testimony, the evidence of a police sentry to whom the appellant allegedly confessed to inflicting injuries on his brother and the post mortem report which found that the deceased head had been separated from the body at the upper end of the neck.

The Court observed:

“On considering all the above, we find that the Doctor's evidence corroborates the evidence of PW-1 and PW-3 and proves that the appellant was the only person who had inflicted the injuries on the deceased with a dao.”

Finding that the eyewitness account was truthful and corroborated by other evidence, the High Court held that the defects in investigation did not go to the root of the case. It concluded:

“The above leaves us with no doubt that defect in investigation, if any, does not go to the root of the issue for finding out the truth, which is the fact that the Prosecution has been able to prove the guilt of the appellant, beyond all reasonable doubt, as having committed the offence punishable under Sections 448 and 302 IPC.”

Accordingly, the High Court dismissed the appeal and upheld the conviction and life sentence under Section 302 IPC.

Counsel for Appellant: Mrs. P.B. Bordoloi

Counsel for Respondent: Mr. R.R. Kaushik, Additional Public Prosecutor

Tags: