Recruitment Benefits Not Disclosed To Candidates Can't Be Denied For Failure To Claim Them: Kerala High Court
The Kerala High Court has held that Kerala Public Service Commission (KPSC) cannot deny entitlement to weightage marks for additional academic qualifications such as M.Phil, Ph.D, and Postdoctoral Fellowship to candidates to the post of Assistant Professor on the ground that the candidates failed to claim them in their applications, when the availability of the weightage was not disclosed in...
The Kerala High Court has held that Kerala Public Service Commission (KPSC) cannot deny entitlement to weightage marks for additional academic qualifications such as M.Phil, Ph.D, and Postdoctoral Fellowship to candidates to the post of Assistant Professor on the ground that the candidates failed to claim them in their applications, when the availability of the weightage was not disclosed in the recruitment notifications.
A Division Bench comprising Justice Anil K. Narendran and Justice Muralee Krishna S. dismissed four original petitions filed by the KPSC challenging a common order passed by the Kerala Administrative Tribunal (KAT), Thiruvananthapuram.
The dispute arose after the KPSC denied weightage marks to several candidates possessing additional academic qualifications, including M.Phil, Ph.D and Postdoctoral Fellowship degrees, on the ground that those qualifications had not been incorporated into their PSC profiles before the last date for submission of applications.
The candidates had acquired the additional qualifications before the respective application deadlines. However, they had not claimed weightage for those qualifications while submitting their applications.
The candidates contended that the recruitment notifications issued in 2019 and 2020 did not contain any provision informing applicants that weightage marks would be awarded for such non-qualifying qualifications. They also pointed out that the application forms initially provided no specific column to claim weightage for M.Phil, Ph.D or Postdoctoral Fellowship qualifications.
The candidates further contended that the relevant PSC circulars and Office Manual provisions were internal documents and had not been brought to their notice before the last date for submitting applications.
Aggrieved by the denial of weightage marks, the candidates approached the Kerala Administrative Tribunal seeking directions to revise the ranked lists by awarding the appropriate additional marks.
By a common order dated September 5, 2024, the Kerala Administrative Tribunal allowed the original applications and declared that the applicants were entitled to weightage marks for their additional qualifications.
The Tribunal directed the KPSC to modify the respective ranked lists by awarding two marks for M.Phil, four marks for Ph.D and five marks for candidates possessing both M.Phil and Ph.D, irrespective of whether the qualifications had been claimed in the applications or incorporated into their profiles before the last date of submission.
The Tribunal also directed that further advice and appointments from the respective ranked lists should be made only after the lists were modified in accordance with its directions.
The KPSC approached the High Court challenging the order of the Tribunal.
The KPSC contended that Clause 16 of the General Conditions of the recruitment notifications clearly stipulated that claims not made in the candidate's profile at the time of submitting the application would not be considered for that particular selection.
According to the Commission, any qualification added to the profile after submission of the application could be considered only for future selections.
The KPSC further maintained that candidates were expected to keep their profiles updated and that weightage marks were awarded only to those who had incorporated the relevant additional qualifications and claimed the benefit before the application deadline.
The Commission also relied on paragraph 381D of its Office Manual and Circular No. 19 of 2022, which prescribed weightage marks for non-qualifying academic qualifications.
The candidates argued that the benefit of weightage marks had not been disclosed in the original recruitment notifications and that they could not be expected to claim a benefit of which they had not been informed.
The High Court examined the difference between the original application forms and the forms generated after the PSC subsequently modified its software.
The Bench noted that the application form submitted by one of the candidates in September 2020 did not contain a specific column for claiming weightage for preferential academic qualifications such as M.Phil, Ph.D and Postdoctoral Fellowship.
However, the application form generated after the candidate updated her profile contained an additional question specifically asking whether she had any weightage claims for such preferential qualifications.
The Court also took note of the PSC's admission before the Tribunal that its earlier application forms contained only eight rows under the head of declarations and that the software had subsequently been updated on February 22, 2022, by incorporating an additional row for entering details of preferential qualifications.
The Bench further examined the application forms and profile details of candidates who had already been awarded weightage marks in the selection process.
The records of candidates, produced by the PSC in sealed covers pursuant to the Court's direction, revealed that although their application forms contained a column for claiming weightage for non-qualifying qualifications, they had answered the question in the negative.
Despite this, the PSC had awarded them weightage marks.
The Court observed that these records contradicted the Commission's contention that weightage marks were granted only to candidates who had specifically claimed the benefit before the last date of submission of applications.
The Bench noted that the original recruitment notifications did not contain any provision indicating that weightage marks would be awarded for additional non-qualifying academic qualifications.
The Court noted that the earlier notification issued by the PSC inviting applications for the respective posts, there was no mention to indicate the weightage marks for any other qualifications acquired by the candidate, while the subsequent notification dated December 30, 2022, expressly incorporated a provision granting weightage marks for M.Phil, Ph.D and Postdoctoral Fellowship qualifications, subject to the stipulated conditions.
The Court also observed that the PSC had not claimed that its Office Manual or Circular No. 19 of 2022, containing the relevant provisions regarding weightage marks, was available in the public domain.
In these circumstances, the Bench held that the Commission could not rely upon internal circulars and Office Manual provisions to contend that candidates had been made aware of the availability of such benefits.
“Without making the candidates aware of such benefits at any time before the last date of submission of the applications, merely by relying on the Office Manual and Circular, PSC cannot raise a contention that the weightage marks will not be awarded to the candidates since they have not claimed that benefit in their applications.” the Court noted.
The Court thus held that the Tribunal had correctly appreciated the relevant facts and legal position, hence dismissed the petitions by PSC.
Counsel for Petitioner: P.C. Sasidharan (SC, KPSC)
Counsel for Respondents: S. Mohammed Al Rafi, Fahad Hussain, N. Nisham, Thajuna Maria Francis, K C Mohamed Rashid, Ann Maria Francis (GP), Jelson K Edampadam, Saji John