Independent Seizure Witnesses Turning Hostile Not By Itself Ground To Disbelieve Drug Recovery At Bail Stage: MP High Court
The Madhya Pradesh High Court has observed that merely because two independent seizure witnesses did not support the prosecution case is not enough to disbelieve the alleged recovery, especially at the stage of the bail application. [2026 LiveLaw (MP) 465]The bench of Justice BP Sharma observed: "Merely because two independent seizure witnesses have not supported the prosecution case, the...
The Madhya Pradesh High Court has observed that merely because two independent seizure witnesses did not support the prosecution case is not enough to disbelieve the alleged recovery, especially at the stage of the bail application. [2026 LiveLaw (MP) 465]
The bench of Justice BP Sharma observed:
"Merely because two independent seizure witnesses have not supported the prosecution case, the alleged recovery cannot be disbelieved at the stage of consideration of bail without examining the remaining prosecution evidence. The effect of their depositions and the alleged procedural irregularities shall be considered by the trial Court during trial".
Per the prosecution, an information was received by the police that the applicant was carrying cough syrup for sale in Satna. The police reached the place and recovered 20 bottles of Onrex Cough Syrup, each containing 100 ml. The syrup allegedly contained codeine and phosphate. Accordingly, the applicant was arrested, and a chargesheet was filed before the competent court.
The counsel for the applicant argued that no contraband was recovered from his seizure. Further, two independent seizure witnesses did not support the prosecution case and denied the alleged recovery in their presence. Further, it was argued that the seized syrup is a medicinal preparation and does not attract the provisions of the NDPS Act. Further, the quantity seized is not a commercial quantity.
The State argued that the 20 bottles seized contained codeine phosphate, which constitutes a commercial quantity under the NDPS Act. It was argued that the applicant failed to produce any licence or valid document authorising possession or sale of such cough syrup.
Referring to the case of Hira Singh v Union of India, the court reiterated that the quantity of neutral substances in a mixture containing narcotic drugs or psychotropic substances must be taken into account along with the actual weight of the offending drug while determining 'small or commercial quantity' under the NDPS.
Rejecting the argument that cough syrup is a medicinal preparation, the court noted that unlicensed transportation of large quantities of codeine-based cough syrup without valid documents falls under the penal provisions, referring to Mohd Sahabuddin v State of Assam [(2012) 13 SCC 49].
In the present case, the court noted that the applicant was not a license holder and failed to produce any valid document justifying his possession. Therefore, the bench held that, per the material available, the applicant was prima facie in possession of a commercial quantity of cough syrup containing codeine phosphate.
Accordingly, the bench dismissed the second bail application.
For Applicant: Advocate Smita Varma
For State: Advocate N.S. Solanki